Highways of Canadian LiteratureLogan, J. D. (John Daniel)
History
Highways of Canadian Literature
Logan, J. D. (John Daniel)
Canadian literature -- History and criticism
But the Australian poets have their _forte_. In realistic pictures of
rough or pioneer social life, they surpass the Canadian poets. The
Canadian poet Drummond, of course, stands in a class by himself,
inasmuch as his poetry of the _habitant_ and _voyageur_ was a field
pre-empted by him and inasmuch as his poetry in this field is devoted to
picturesque revealment of the _humanity_—the pathos and humor—of the
thought, speech and simple life—of a peculiar but morally worthy
people. There is nothing melodramatic in Drummond’s poetry. It is
genuinely humanized verse about a genuinely human people. Service’s
Western and Northern Canadian verse, on the contrary, is the poetry of
picaresque melodrama. The best ballads of the Australian poets of rough
or pioneer life, A. L. Gordon, A. B. Patterson, Henry Lawson, C. J.
Dennis, are authentic poetry. In remarking the distinction between the
Australian and the Canadian poets of rude or picaresque life, Mr. E. B.
Osborn truthfully says: ‘Some of the poems in his [Service’s] last
volume are a _near approach_ to the Australian realism, which avoids the
melodramatic and the splashing of anapests as far as possible and makes
use of the quiet-curtain. So far the manly adventurous poets of Canada
[Service, Stead, McInnes, Fraser, _et al._] have not progressed far
beyond the Adam Lindsay Gordon convention. As yet none of the Western
Canadian poets see that _style_ is the only antiseptic and, as artists,
they are far behind the Australians and compare unfavorably with the
minor masters of Quebec.’
What has been said regarding the technical finish of Australian verse
applies also to the verse of New Zealand and of South Africa, and to the
latter with even more truth. For all the South African poets happened to
be men and women of culture. Thomas Pringle was a man of rare and
refined culture. So are Arthur Cripps, R. C. Russell, John Runcie, Mrs.
Beatrice Bromley, W. C. Scully, and a score of others.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account