Highways of Canadian LiteratureLogan, J. D. (John Daniel)
History
Highways of Canadian Literature
Logan, J. D. (John Daniel)
Canadian literature -- History and criticism
The best account of the War of 1812 came from the pen of Major John
Richardson, who had served in the conflict. It is the account of an
eye-witness. It was written hurriedly for publication serially in his
newspaper the _New Era_, and was reprinted in book form in 1842. As
might be expected, Richardson presents vividly the drama or dramatic
movement of his story, and makes it a colorful, gripping narrative. But
though, like Haliburton, Richardson wrote graphically, romantically, he
is superior to Haliburton in an important respect. The Nova Scotia
historian and humorist did not have any gift for sharp
character-drawing; his characters, like Dickens’ or Twain’s, stand out
and hold us by what they say. But Richardson’s characters in his account
of the War of 1812, especially Brock and Tecumseh, are vividly drawn by
their _action_, and stand out sharply individualized. In Haliburton’s
_Historical Account of Nova Scotia_ we get only colorful romance. In
Richardson’s _War of 1812_ we get colorful romance, dramatic movement,
and memorable character portraiture. It, too, is ‘true history,’ and his
work, like Haliburton’s, is an outstanding native example of the
romantic method of writing history as literature.
After Haliburton and Richardson, all history of Canada, or the
Provinces, by native-born or _émigré_ writers was fragmentary in
conception and dry-as-dust in matter and method. They all show
inquisitiveness, diligence, though not careful research, and no
imagination, and certainly no sense of history as the outward expression
and movement of a people’s social and spiritual evolution. Yet the work
of one man must be specially remarked. He was Alpheus Todd, who, in the
department of Constitutional History, wrote a work which was long
regarded as the greatest study of the English constitution written by
any British subject. This really ‘monumental’ historical work was
entitled _Parliamentary Government in England; its Origin, Development,
and Practical Operation_. The first volume was published in 1867, the
year of Canadian Confederation. But while Todd’s work is a ‘monument’ to
his scholarship and industry, and while it has historic perspective, it
is, like the work of preceding historians, without imagination and was
written by one who had no conception of constitutional history as the
expression of the social conscience gradually realizing, under changing
conditions, the ideal of the rights of the spirit.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account