History of American SocialismsNoyes, John Humphrey
History
History of American Socialisms
Noyes, John Humphrey
Communism -- United States; Socialism -- United States
"These daring and original spirits arrange themselves in three
classes; the merely Theoretical; the simply Practical; and the
Theoretico-Practical combined. In other words, the Social
Architects whom we propose to consider, may be described as
those who ideally plan the new structure of society; those who
set immediately to work to make a new structure, without any
very large and comprehensive plan; and those who have both
devised a plan and attempted its actual execution.
"I. The Theoretical class is one which is most numerous, but
whose claims are the least worthy of attention. [Under this
head, Mr. Godwin mentions Plato, Sir Thomas More and Harrington,
and discusses their imaginative projects--the Republic, Utopia
and Oceana.]
"II. The Practical Architects of Society, or the Communities
instituted to exemplify a more perfect state of social life.
[The Essenes, Moravians, Shakers and Rappites are mentioned
under this head.]
"III. The Theoretico-Practical Architects of Society, or those
who have combined the enunciation of general principles of
social organization with actual experiments, of whom the best
representatives are St. Simon, Robert Owen and Charles Fourier.
This class will extend the basis of our inquiries, and demand a
more elaborate consideration."
This classification, if it had not gone beyond the popular pamphlet in
which it was started, might have been left without criticism. But it
is substantially reproduced in the New American Cyclopaedia under the
head of "Socialism," and thus has become a standard doctrine. We will
therefore point out what we conceive to be its errors, and indicate a
truer classification.
In the first place, from the account of St. Simon and Fourier which
Mr. Godwin himself gives immediately after the last of his three
headings, it is clear that they did _not_ belong to the
theoretico-practical class. St. Simon undertook to perfect himself in
all knowledge, and for this purpose experimented in many things, good
and bad; but it does not appear that he ever tried his hand at
Communism or Association of any kind. He published a book called "New
Christianity," of which Godwin says:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account