History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)Taine, Hippolyte
History
History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)
Taine, Hippolyte
English literature -- History and criticism
In this crowd two men have appeared of superior talent, original and
contrasted, popular on the same grounds, ministers to the same cause,
moralists in comedy and drama, defenders of natural sentiments against
social institutions; who, by the precision of their pictures, the depth
of their observations, the succession and bitterness of their attacks,
have renewed, with other views and in another style, the old combative
spirit of Swift and Fielding.
One, more ardent, more expansive, wholly given up to rapture, an
impassioned painter of crude and dazzling pictures, a lyric
prose-writer, omnipotent in laughter and tears, plunged into fantastic
invention, painful sensibility, vehement buffoonery; and by the boldness
of his style, the excess of his emotions, the grotesque familiarity of
his caricatures, he has displayed all the forces and weaknesses of an
artist, all the audacities, all the successes, and all the oddities of
the imagination.
The other, more contained, better informed and stronger, a lover
of moral dissertations, a counsellor of the public, a sort of
lay preacher, less bent on defending the poor, more bent on
censuring man, has brought to the aid of satire a sustained
common-sense, a great knowledge of the heart, consummate cleverness,
powerful reasoning, a treasure of meditated hatred, and has persecuted
vice with all the weapons of reflection. By this contrast the one
completes the other; and we may form an exact idea of English taste by
placing the portrait of William Makepeace Thackeray by the side of that
of Charles Dickens.
Part I.--The Satirist
Section I.--The English Satirist
No wonder if in England a novelist writes satires. A gloomy and
reflective man is impelled to it by his character; he is still further
impelled by the surrounding manners. He is not permitted to contemplate
passions as poetic powers; he is bidden to appreciate them as moral
qualities. His pictures become sentences; he is a counsellor rather than
an observer, a judge rather than an artist. We see by what machinery
Thackeray has changed novel into satire.
I open at random his three great works--"Pendennis, Vanity Fair, The
Newcomes." Every scene sets in relief a moral truth: the author desires
that at every page we should form a judgment on vice and virtue; he has
blamed or approved beforehand, and the dialogues or portraits are to him
only means by which he adds our approbation to his approbation, our
blame to his blame. He is giving us lessons; and beneath the sentiments
which he describes, as beneath the events which he relates, we
continually discover rules for our conduct and the intentions of a
reformer.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive