History of European Morals From Augustus to Charlemagne (Vol. 2 of 2)Lecky, William Edward Hartpole
Philosophy
History of European Morals From Augustus to Charlemagne (Vol. 2 of 2)
Lecky, William Edward Hartpole
Ethics; Europe -- Moral conditions
It must be observed, however, that the beneficial influence of the
monastic system was necessarily transitional, and the subsequent
corruption the normal and inevitable result of its constitution. Vast
societies living in enforced celibacy, exercising an unbounded influence,
and possessing enormous wealth, must necessarily have become hotbeds of
corruption when the enthusiasm that had created them expired. The services
they rendered as the centres of agriculture, the refuge of travellers, the
sanctuaries in war, the counterpoise of the baronial castle, were no
longer required when the convulsions of invasion had ceased and when civil
society was definitely organised. And a similar observation may be
extended even to their moral type. Thus, while it is undoubtedly true that
the Benedictine monks, by making labour an essential element of their
discipline, did very much to efface the stigma which slavery had affixed
upon it, it is also true that, when industry had passed out of its initial
stage, the monastic theories of the sanctity of poverty, and the evil of
wealth, were its most deadly opponents. The dogmatic condemnation by
theologians of loans at interest, which are the basis of industrial
enterprise, was the expression of a far deeper antagonism of tendencies
and ideals.
In one important respect, the transition from the eremite to the monastic
life involved not only a change of circumstances, but also a change of
character. The habit of obedience, and the virtue of humility, assumed a
position which they had never previously occupied. The conditions of the
hermit life contributed to develop to a very high degree a spirit of
independence and spiritual pride, which was still further increased by a
curious habit that existed in the Church of regarding each eminent hermit
as the special model or professor of some particular virtue, and making
pilgrimages to him, in order to study this aspect of his character.(393)
These pilgrimages, combined with the usually solitary and self-sufficing
life of the hermit, and also with the habit of measuring progress almost
entirely by the suppression of a physical appetite, which it is quite
possible wholly to destroy, very naturally produced an extreme
arrogance.(394) But in the highly organised and disciplined monasteries of
the West, passive obedience and humility were the very first things that
were inculcated. The monastery, beyond all other institutions, was the
school for their exercise; and as the monk represented the highest moral
ideal of the age, obedience and humility acquired a new value in the minds
of men. Nearly all the feudal and other organisations that arose out of
the chaos that followed the destruction of the Roman Empire were
intimately related to the Church, not simply because the Church was the
strongest power in Christendom, and supplied in itself an admirable model
of an organised body, but also because it had done much to educate men in
habits of obedience.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account