This is a specimen of the manner in which the seeds of Grecian
mythus came to be distributed over so large a surface. To an
ordinary Greek reader, these legendary discoveries of Asklepiadês
would probably be more interesting than the positive facts
which he communicated respecting the Iberian tribes; and his
Turditanian auditors would be delighted to hear—while he was
reciting and explaining to them the animated passage of the
Iliad, in which Agamemnôn extols the inestimable value of the bow
of Teukros (viii. 281)—that the heroic archer and his companions
had actually set foot in the Iberian peninsula.
[599] This was the opinion of Kratês of Mallus, one of the
most distinguished of the critics on Homer: it was the subject
of an animated controversy between him and Aristarchus (Aulus
Gellius, N. A. xiv. 6; Strabo, iii. p. 157). See the instructive
treatise of Lehrs, De Aristarchi Studiis, c. v. § 4. p. 251.
Much controversy also took place among the critics respecting
the ground which Menelaus went over in his wanderings (Odyss.
iv.). Kratês affirmed that he had circumnavigated the southern
extremity of Africa and gone to India: the critic Aristonikus,
Strabo’s contemporary, enumerated all the different opinions
(Strabo, i. p. 38).
[600] Strabo, iii. p. 157.
[601] Strabo, i. p. 22-44; vii. p. 299.
The fabulous island of Erytheia,—the residence of the three headed
Geryôn with his magnificent herd of oxen, under the custody of the
two-headed dog Orthrus, and described by Hesiod, like the garden of
the Hesperides, as extra-terrestrial, on the farther side of the
circumfluous ocean;—this island was supposed by the interpreters of
Stesichorus the poet to be named by him off the south-western region
of Spain called Tartêssus, and in the immediate vicinity of Gadês. But
the historian Hekatæus, in his anxiety to historicize the old fable,
took upon himself to remove Erytheia from Spain nearer home to Epirus.
He thought it incredible that Hêraklês should have traversed Europe
from east to west, for the purpose of bringing the cattle of Geryôn to
Eurystheus at Mykênæ, and he pronounced Geryôn to have been a king of
Epirus, near the Gulf of Ambrakia. The oxen reared in that neighborhood
were proverbially magnificent, and to get them even from thence and
bring them to Mykênæ (he contended) was no inconsiderable task. Arrian,
who cites this passage from Hekatæus, concurs in the same view,—an
illustration of the license with which ancient authors fitted on their
fabulous geographical names to the real earth, and brought down the
ethereal matter of legend to the lower atmosphere of history.[602]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account