Both metropolitans and colonists styled themselves Hellens, and were
recognized as such by each other; all glorying in the name as the
prominent symbol of fraternity;—all describing non-Hellenic men, or
cities, by a word which involved associations of repugnance. Our
term _barbarian_, borrowed from this latter word, does not express
the same idea; for the Greeks spoke thus indiscriminately of the
extra-Hellenic world, with all its inhabitants;[364] whatever might
be the gentleness of their character, and whatever might be their
degree of civilization. The rulers and people of Egyptian Thebes,
with their ancient and gigantic monuments, the wealthy Tyrians and
Carthaginians, the phil-Hellene Arganthonius of Tartêssus, and
the well-disciplined patricians of Rome (to the indignation of
old Cato,[365]) were all comprised in it. At first, it seemed to
have expressed more of repugnance than of contempt, and repugnance
especially towards the sound of a foreign language.[366] Afterwards,
a feeling of their own superior intelligence (in part well justified)
arose among the Greeks, and their term _barbarian_ was used so as to
imply a low state of the temper and intelligence; in which sense it
was retained by the semi-Hellenized Romans, as the proper antithesis
to their state of civilization. The want of a suitable word,
corresponding to _barbarian_, as the Greeks originally used it, is so
inconvenient in the description of Grecian phenomena and sentiments,
that I may be obliged occasionally to use the word in its primitive
sense.
[364] See the protest of Eratosthenês against the continuance of
the classification into Greek and Barbarian, after the latter
word had come to imply rudeness (ap. Strabo. ii. p. 66; Eratosth.
Fragm. Seidel. p. 85).
[365] Cato, Fragment. ed. Lion. p. 46; ap. Plin. H. N. xxii. 1.
A remarkable extract from Cato’s letter to his son, intimating
his strong antipathy to the Greeks; he proscribes their medicine
altogether, and admits only a slight taste of their literature:
“Quod bonum sit eorum literas inspicere, non per discere....
Jurarunt inter se, Barbaros necare omnes medicinâ, sed hoc ipsum
mercede faciunt, ut fides iis sit et facile disperdant. Nos
quoque dictitant Barbaros et spurios, nosque magis quam alios,
Opicos appellatione fœdant.”
[366] Καρῶν ἠγήσατο βαρβαροφώνων, Homer, Iliad, ii. 867. Homer
does not use the word βάρβαροι, or any words signifying either
a Hellen generally or a non-Hellen generally (Thucyd. i. 3).
Compare Strabo, viii. p. 370; and xiv. p. 662.
Ovid reproduces the primitive sense of the word βάρβαρος, when he
speaks of himself as an exile at Tomi (Trist. v. 10-37):—
“Barbarus hic ego sum, quia non intelligor ulli.”
The Egyptians had a word in their language, the exact equivalent
of βάρβαρος in this sense (Herod. ii. 158).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account