[254] Herodot. i, 59. I record this allusion to Nisæa and the
Megarian war, because I find it distinctly stated in Herodotus;
and because it _may_ possibly refer to some other _later_
war between Athens and Megara than that which is mentioned
in Plutarch’s Life of Solon as having taken place before the
Solonian legislation (that is, before 594 B. C.), and therefore
nearly forty years before this movement of Peisistratus to
acquire the despotism. Peisistratus must then have been so young
that he could not with any propriety be said to have “captured
Nisæa” (Νισαιάν τε ἑλών): moreover, the public reputation, which
was found useful to the ambition of Peisistratus in 560 B. C.,
must have rested upon something more recent than his bravery
displayed about 597 B. C.; just as the celebrity which enabled
Napoleon to play the game of successful ambition on the 18th
Brumaire (Nov. 1799) was obtained by victories gained within the
preceding five years, and could not have been represented by any
historian as resting upon victories gained in the Seven Years’
war, between 1756-1763.
At the same time, my belief is that the words of Herodotus
respecting Peisistratus do really refer to the Megarian war
mentioned in Plutarch’s Life of Solon, and that Herodotus
supposed that Megarian war to have been much more near to the
despotism of Peisistratus than it really was. In the conception
of Herodotus, and by what (after Niebuhr) I venture to call a
mistake in his chronology, the interval between 600-560 B. C.
shrinks from forty years to little or nothing. Such mistake
appears, not only on the present occasion, but also upon two
others: first, in regard to the alleged dialogue between Solon
and Crœsus, described and commented upon a few pages above; next,
in regard to the poet Alkæus and his inglorious retreat before
the Athenian troops at Sigeium and Achilleium, where he lost
his shield, when the Mityleneans were defeated. The reality of
this incident is indisputable, since it was mentioned by Alkæus
himself in one of his songs; but Herodotus represents it to have
occurred in an Athenian expedition _directed by Peisistratus_.
Now the war in which Alkæus incurred this misfortune, and which
was brought to a close by the mediation of Periander of Corinth,
must have taken place earlier than 584 B. C., and probably took
place before the legislation of Solon; long before the time when
Peisistratus had the direction of Athenian affairs,—though the
latter may have carried on, and probably did carry on, _another
and a later war_ against the Mityleneans in those regions, which
led to the introduction of his illegitimate son, Hegesistratus,
as despot of Sigeium (Herod. v. 94-95).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account