On one point, however, the author of the story seems to have
overlooked both the exigencies of chronology and the historical
position and feelings of his hero Kleisthenês. For among the
suitors who present themselves at Sikyôn in conformity with
the invitation of the latter, one is Leôkêdês, son of Pheidôn
the despot of Argos. Now the hostility and vehement antipathy
towards Argos, which Herodotus ascribes in another place to
the Sikyonian Kleisthenês, renders it all but impossible that
the son of any king of Argos could have become a candidate for
the hand of Agaristê. I have already recounted the violence
which Kleisthenês did to the legendary sentiment of his native
town, and the insulting names which he put upon the Sikyonian
Dorians,—all under the influence of a strong anti-Argeian
feeling. Next, as to chronology: Pheidôn king of Argos lived some
time between 760-730; and his son can never have been a candidate
for the daughter of Kleisthenês, whose reign falls 600-500 B.
C. Chronologers resort here to the usual resource in cases of
difficulty: they recognize a second and later Pheidôn, whom they
affirm that Herodotus has confounded with the first: or they
alter the text of Herodotus, and in place of “son of Pheidôn,”
read “descendant of Pheidôn.” But neither of these conjectures
rests upon any basis: the text of Herodotus is smooth and clear,
and the second Pheidôn is nowhere else authenticated. See Larcher
and Wesseling, _ad loc._; compare also vol. ii, p. 419, part ii,
ch. 4, of this History.
Plutarch numbers Æschinês of Sikyôn[53] among the despots put down by
Sparta: at what period this took place, or how it is to be connected
with the history of Kleisthenês as given in Herodotus, we are unable
to say.
[53] Plutarch, De Herod. Malign. c. 21, p. 859.
Contemporaneous with the Orthagoridæ at Sikyôn,—but beginning a
little later and closing somewhat earlier,—we find the despots
Kypselus and Periander at Corinth. The former appears as the
subverter of the oligarchy called the Bacchiadæ. Of the manner in
which he accomplished his object we find no information: and this
historical blank is inadequately filled up by various religious
prognostics and oracles, foreshadowing the rise, the harsh rule, and
the dethronement, after two generations, of these powerful despots.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account