“Mihi hæc verba, quum illud quidem manifestum faciant, quod etiam
aliunde constat, sorte captos ephoros non esse, tum hoc alterum,
quod Hermannus statuit, creationem sortitioni non absimilem
fuisse, nequaquam demonstrare videntur. Nimirum nihil aliud nisi
prope accedere ephororum magistratus ad cos dicitur, qui sortito
capiantur. _Sortitis autem magistratibus hoc maxime proprium est,
ut promiscue—non ex genere, censu, dignitate—a quolibet capi
possint_: quamobrem quum ephori quoque fere promiscue fierent ex
omni multitudine civium, poterat haud dubie magistratus eorum
ἐγγὺς τῆς κληρωτῆς δυνάμεως esse dici, etiamsi αἱρετοὶ essent—h.
e. suffragiis creati. Et video Lachmannum quoque, p. 165, not. 1,
de Platonis loco similiter judicare.”
The employment of the lot, as Schömann remarks, implies universal
admissibility of all citizens to office: though the converse does
not hold good,—the latter does not of necessity imply the former.
Now, as we know that universal admissibility did not become
the law of Athens until after the battle of Platæa, so we may
conclude that the employment of the lot had no place before that
epoch,—_i. e._ had no place under the constitution of Kleisthenês.
[261] Plutarch, Periklês, c. 9-16.
[262] See a passage about such characters in Plato, Republic, v,
p. 475 B.
I think, therefore, that these three points: 1. The opening of the
post of archon to all citizens indiscriminately; 2. The choice of
archons by lot; 3. The diminished range of the archon’s duties and
responsibilities, through the extension of those belonging to the
popular courts of justice on the one hand and to the stratêgi on the
other—are all connected together, and must have been simultaneous,
or nearly simultaneous, in the time of introduction: the enactment
of universal admissibility to office certainly not coming after the
other two, and probably coming a little before them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account