Nevertheless, subsequent observations, recently made known by
Colonel Rawlinson to the Geographical Society, have contradicted
the views of Dr. Ross as stated above, and shown that the Wall
of Media, in the line here assigned to it, has no evidence to
rest upon. Captain Jones, commander of the steamer at Bagdad,
undertook, at the request of Colonel Rawlinson a minute
examination of the locality, and ascertained that what had been
laid down as the Wall of Media was merely a line of mounds;
no wall at all, but a mere embankment, extending seven or
eight miles from the Tigris, and designed to arrest the winter
torrents and drain off the rain water of the desert into a large
reservoir, which served to irrigate an extensive valley between
the rivers.
From this important communication it results, that there is as
yet no evidence now remaining for determining what was the line
or position of the Wall of Media; which had been supposed to be
a datum positively established, serving as premises from whence
to deduce other positions mentioned by Xenophon. As our knowledge
now stands, there is not a single point mentioned by Xenophon
in Babylonia which can be positively verified, except Babylon
itself,—and Pylæ, which is known pretty nearly, as the spot
where Babylonia proper commences.
The description which Xenophon gives of the Wall of Media is very
plain and specific. I see no reason to doubt that he actually
saw it, passed through it, and correctly describes it in height
as well as breadth. Its entire length he of course only gives
from what he was told. His statement appears to me good evidence
that there was a Wall of Media, which reached from the Tigris to
the Euphrates, or perhaps to some canal cut from the Euphrates,
though there exists no mark to show what was the precise locality
and direction of the Wall. Ammianus Marcellinus (xxiv, 2), in
the expedition of the emperor Julian, saw near Macepracta, on
the left bank of the Euphrates, the ruins of a wall, “which in
ancient times had stretched to a great distance for the defence
of Assyria against foreign invasion.” It is fair to presume that
this was the Wall of Media; but the position of Macepracta cannot
be assigned.
It is important, however, to remember,—what I have already
stated in this note,—that Xenophon did not see, and did not
cross either the Wall of Media, or the two canals here mentioned,
until many days after the battle of Kunaxa.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account