This swelling of the rivers begins about June; they do not attain
their full height until August. Moreover, the description of the
battle, as given both by Arrian and by Curtius, implies that it
took place after the rainy season had begun (Arrian, v. 9, 7; v.
12, 5. Curtius, viii. 14, 4).
Some critics have proposed to read _Metageitnion_ (July-August)
as the month, instead of _Munychion_; an alteration approved by
Mr. Clinton and received into the text by Schmieder. But if this
alteration be admitted, the name of the Athenian archon must be
altered also; for Metageitnion of the archon Hegemon would be
eight months earlier (July-August, 327 B. C.); and at
this date Alexander had not as yet crossed the Indus, as the
passage of Aristobulus (ap. Strabo. xv. p. 691) plainly shows—and
as Droysen and Mützel remark. Alexander did not cross the Indus
before the spring of 326 B. C. If, in place of the
archon Hegemon, we substitute the next following archon Chremês
(and it is remarkable that Diodorus assigns the battle to this
later archonship, xvii. 87), this would be July-August 326 B. C.;
which would be a more admissible date for the battle than the
preceding month of Munychion. At the same time, the substitution
of Metageitnion _is_ mere conjecture; and seems to leave hardly
time enough for the subsequent events. As far as an opinion can
be formed, it would seem that the battle was fought about the end
of June or beginning of July 326 B. C. after the rainy season had
commenced; towards the close of the archonship of Hegemon, and
the beginning of that of Chremes.
[542] Arrian, v. 20; Diodor. xvii. 95. Lieut. Wood (Journey to
the source of the Oxus, p. 11-39) remarks that the large rivers
of the Punjab change their course so often and so considerably,
that monuments and indications of Alexander’s march in that
territory cannot be expected to remain, especially in ground near
rivers.
[543] Arrian, v. 20.
[544] Arrian, v, 23, 24; Curtius, ix. 1, 15.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account