The elaborate article of Droysen (in the Appendix to his
Geschichte des Hellenismus, p. 588-651), ascribes to Alexander
the largest plans of colonization in Asia, and enumerates a
great number of cities alleged to have been founded by him. But
in regard to the majority of these foundations, the evidence
upon which Droysen grounds his belief that Alexander was the
founder, appears to me altogether slender and unsatisfactory. If
Alexander founded so many cities as Droysen imagines, how does it
happen that Arrian mentions only so comparatively small a number?
The argument derived from Arrian’s silence, for rejecting what
is affirmed by other ancients respecting Alexander, is indeed
employed by modern authors (and by Droysen himself among them),
far oftener than I think warrantable. But if there be any one
proceeding of Alexander more than another, in respect of which
the silence of Arrian ought to make us suspicious—it is the
foundation of a new colony; a solemn act, requiring delay and
multiplied regulations, intended for perpetuity, and redounding
to the honor of the founder. I do not believe in any colonies
founded by Alexander, beyond those comparatively few which Arrian
mentions, except such as rest upon some other express and good
testimony. Whoever will read through Droysen’s list, will see
that most of the names in it will not stand this test. The short
life, and rapid movements, of Alexander, are of themselves the
strongest presumption against his having founded so large a
number of colonies.
[646] Diodor. xvii. 99; xviii. 7. Curtius, ix. 7, 1. Curtius
observes (vii. 10, 15) respecting Alexander’s colonies in
Sogdiana—that they were founded “velut fræni domitarum gentium;
nunc originis suæ oblita serviunt, quibus imperaverunt.”
[647] See the plain-spoken outburst of the Thurian Antileon, one
of the soldiers in Xenophon’s Ten Thousand Greeks, when the army
reached Trapezus (Xenoph. Anabas. v. 1, 2).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account