remedied by taxation of a penal character,—taxation, I mean, in
the nature of a fine for the abatement of a nuisance. In Prince
Edward Island this evil has attained its maximum. It has been
long and loudly complained of, but without any effect. The
people, their representative assembly, the legislative council,
and the governor have cordially concurred in devising a remedy
for it. All their efforts have proved in vain. Some influence—it
cannot be that of equity or reason—has steadily counteracted the
measures of the colonial legislature. I cannot imagine it is any
other influence than that of the absentee proprietors resident
in England; and in saying so I do but express the universal
opinion of the colony. The only question, therefore, as it
appears to me, is whether that influence shall prevail against
the deliberate acts of the colonial legislature and the
universal complaints of the suffering colonists. I can have no
doubt on the subject. My decided opinion is, that the royal
assent should no longer be withheld from the act of the colonial
legislature.
“At the same time, I doubt whether this act will prove a
sufficient remedy for the evil in question. It was but natural
that the colonial legislature—who have found it impossible as
yet to obtain any remedy whatever—should hesitate to propose a
sufficient one. Undeterred by any such consideration,—relying on
the cordial coöperation of the government and parliament in the
work of improving the state of the colonies,—I had intended,
before the receipt of your lordship’s despatch, and still
intend, to suggest a measure which, while it provides a
sufficient remedy for the evil suffered by the colonists, shall
also prove advantageous to the absent proprietors by rendering
their property more valuable. Whether the inhabitants of Prince
Edward Island prefer waiting for the now uncertain results of a
suggestion of mine, or that the act which they have passed
should be at once confirmed, I cannot tell; but I venture
earnestly to recommend that Her Majesty’s government should be
guided by their wishes on the subject; and in order to ascertain
these, I propose to transmit a copy of the present despatch to
Sir Charles FitzRoy, with a request that he will, after
consulting with the leading men of the colony, address your
lordship on the subject.
“With respect to the terms proposed by the proprietors, I am
clearly of opinion that any such arrangement would be wholly
inadequate to the end in view.
“I am, &c.,
“Durham.
“Lord Glenelg.”
The reference in the closing paragraph of the despatch is evidently to a
memorandum of terms proposed by the proprietors for the sale and
settlement of land in the island, and forwarded to Lord Genelg by Mr. G.
R. Young, their talented solicitor and counsel, in January, 1838.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account