History of Spanish and Portuguese Literature (Vol 1 of 2)Bouterwek, Friedrich
History
History of Spanish and Portuguese Literature (Vol 1 of 2)
Bouterwek, Friedrich
Portuguese literature -- History and criticism; Spanish literature -- History and criticism
On a comparison of the dramas of Calderon and Lope de Vega, it requires
no extraordinary critical penetration to discover the essential
services which the former rendered to the dramatic literature of Spain.
Which of these writers possessed the greater share of inventive talent,
is a question which it would be difficult to determine, for Lope de
Vega was not the inventor of that species of dramatic composition
which was common to both, and Calderon was not behind him in the
invention of new combinations of intrigue, ingenious complexities of
plot, and interesting situations. In general the invention of Lope
may be the bolder, but it is also the more rude of the two; and with
regard to whatever may be called refinement, whether in conception or
execution, but more particularly in style, Calderon formed for himself
an entirely new sphere. The delicate art with which he gave the last
polish to the Spanish drama, without changing its nature, carries with
it an ennobling dignity in some of his historical, or, as they are
styled, heroic comedies. In his comedies of intrigue this delicacy is
conspicuous in the execution of the general forms of character, which
had now become naturalized on the Spanish stage, and which usurped
the place of individuality. Calderon’s comedies are necessarily as
little pieces of character as those of Lope de Vega, for with the
delineation of particular character they would have ceased to be pure
dramas of intrigue. But they abound in characteristic traits, in those
traits which develope, as it were, out of the souls of the dramatic
personages, the natural course of the gay intrigue in all its various
modifications. As an acute observer of the female mind and manners
Calderon was infinitely superior to Lope de Vega. This delicacy of
observation accords admirably with the almost incredible subtlety
of his combinations of intrigue; and the elegance of his language
and versification complete the ingenious harmony of these apparently
irregular dramas, which though not sufficiently perfect to be regarded
as models, are nevertheless true to the rules which the author
prescribed to himself. The other merits which belong to his dramas,
such as the seductive gracefulness and facility of the dialogue,
Calderon shares in common with all the good dramatic writers of Spain.
The faults with which he may be reproached, and which in some measure
belong to the species of drama he adopted, are more numerous in some of
his pieces than in others. It must also be observed, that in some of
his heroic comedies, he sinks so completely beneath his own standard
that it is difficult to recognize him.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account