The Executive Commission met and placarded a proclamation: "The royalist conspirators have attacked; despite the moderation of our attitude, they have attacked. Our duty is to defend the great city against these culpable aggressions." In the Commission, the generals Duval, Bergeret, and Eudes declared for an attack. "The enthusiasm," they said, "is irresistible, unique. What can Versailles do against 100,000 men? We must sally out." Their colleagues resisted, especially Felix Pyat, confronted with his rant and vapourings of the morning. His poltroonery stood him in the stead of a life-preserver. "One does not start," said he, "at random, without cannon, without _cadres_, and without chiefs;" and he demanded the return of the strength of the troops. Duval, who since the 19th March had been strongly bent upon a sortie, violently apostrophised him: "Why, then, for three days have you shouted, 'To Versailles?'" The most energetic opponent of the sortie was Lefrancais. Finally, the four civil members--that is, the majority--decided that the generals should present a detailed statement as to their forces in men, artillery, munitions, and transports. The same evening the Commission named Cluseret delegate at War jointly with Eudes, who, being a member of the so-called party of action, owed this post only to the patronage of his old cronies. In spite of the majority of the Commission, the generals set out. They had, besides, received no formal order to the contrary. Felix Pyat had even concluded by saying, "After all, if you think you are ready...." They saw Flourens always ready for a _coup-de-main_, other colleagues equally adventurous, and, on their own authority, certain of being followed by the National Guard. They sent to the _chefs-de-legion_ the order to form columns. The battalions of the right bank were to concentrate at the Place Vendome and Place Wagram; those of the left bank, at the Place d'Italie and Champ-de-Mars. These movements, without staff officers to guide them, were very badly executed. Many men marched hither and thither, grew tired. Yet at midnight there were still about 20,000 men on the right bank of the Seine and about 17,000 on the left. From eight o'clock to midnight the Council was sitting. The inexorable Felix Pyat, always pertinent, demanded the abolition of the budget of public worship. The majority immediately satisfied him. He might just as well have decreed the abolition of the Versaillese army. Of the sortie, of the military preparations deafening Paris, no one breathed a word in the Council--no one disputed the field with the generals.