History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
1. _Natural Bias to Authority._--It is very evident that, in such a
bias of men's studies, there is something very natural; however
strained and technical this erudition may have been, the
propensities on which it depends are very general, and are easily
seen. Deference to the authority of thoughtful and sagacious men, a
disposition which men in general neither reject nor think they ought
to reject in practical matters, naturally clings to them, even in
speculation. It is a satisfaction to us to suppose that there are,
or have been, minds of transcendent powers, of wide and wise views,
superior to the common errors and blindness of our nature. The
pleasure of admiration, and the repose of confidence, are
inducements to such a belief. There are also other reasons why we
willingly believe that there are in philosophy great teachers, so
profound and sagacious, that, in order to arrive at truth, we have
only to learn their thoughts, to understand their writings. There is
a peculiar interest which men feel in dealing with the thoughts of
their fellow-men, rather than with brute matter. Matter feels and
excites no sympathies: in seeking for mere laws of nature, there is
nothing of mental intercourse with the great spirits of the past, as
there is in {203} studying Aristotle or Plato. Moreover, a large
portion of this employment is of a kind the most agreeable to most
speculative minds; it consists in tracing the consequences of
assumed principles: it is deductive like geometry: and the
principles of the teachers being known, and being undisputed, the
deduction and application of their results is an obvious,
self-satisfying, and inexhaustible exercise of ingenuity.
These causes, and probably others, make criticism and commentation
flourish, when invention begins to fail, oppressed and bewildered by
the acquisitions it has already made; and when the vigor and hope of
men's minds are enfeebled by civil and political changes.
Accordingly,[20\4] the Alexandrian school was eminently
characterized by a spirit of erudition, of literary criticism, of
interpretation, of imitation. These practices, which reigned first
in their full vigor in "the Museum," are likely to be, at all times,
the leading propensities of similar academical institutions.
[Note 20\4: Degerando, _Hist. des Syst. de Philos._ iii. p. 134.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account