History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
The reader will find an interesting view of the _School of
Alexandria_, in M. Barthelemy Saint-Hilaire's _Rapport_ on the
_Mémoires_ sent to the Academy of Moral and Political Sciences at
Paris, in consequence of its having, in 1841, proposed this as the
subject of a prize, which was awarded in 1844. M. Saint-Hilaire has
prefixed to this _Rapport_ a dissertation on the Mysticism of that
school. He, however, uses the term _Mysticism_ in a wider sense than
my purpose, which regarded mainly the bearing of the doctrines of
this school upon the progress of the Inductive Sciences, has led me
to do. Although he finds much to {216} admire in the Alexandrian
philosophy, he declares that they were incapable of treating
scientific questions. The extent to which this is true is well
illustrated by the extract which he gives from Plotinus, on the
question, "Why objects appear smaller in proportion as they are more
distant." Plotinus denies that the reason of this is that the angles
of vision become smaller. His reason for this denial is curious
enough. If it were so, he says, how could the heaven appear smaller
than it is, since it occupies the whole of the visual angle?
2. _Mystical Arithmetic._--It is unnecessary further to exemplify,
from Proclus, the general mystical character of the school and time
to which he belonged; but we may notice more specially one of the
forms of this mysticism, which very frequently offers itself to our
notice, especially in him; and which we may call _Mystical
Arithmetic_. Like all the kinds of Mysticism, this consists in the
attempt to connect our conceptions of external objects by general
and inappropriate notions of goodness, perfection, and relation to
the divine essence and government; instead of referring such
conceptions to those appropriate ideas, which, by due attention,
become perfectly distinct, and capable of being positively applied
and verified. The subject which is thus dealt with, in the doctrines
of which we now speak, is Number; a notion which tempts men into
these visionary speculations more naturally than any other. For
number is really applicable to moral notions--to emotions and
feelings, and to their objects--as well as to the things of the
material world. Moreover, by the discovery of the principle of
musical concords, it had been found, probably most unexpectedly,
that numerical relations were closely connected with sounds which
could hardly be distinguished from the expression of thought and
feeling; and a suspicion might easily arise, that the universe, both
of matter and of thought, might contain many general and abstract
truths of some analogous kind. The relations of number have so wide
a bearing, that the ramifications of such a suspicion could not
easily be exhausted, supposing men willing to follow them into
darkness and vagueness; which it is precisely the mystical tendency
to do. Accordingly, this kind of speculation appeared very early,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account