History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
Physics does not originally and properly form any prominent part of
the Scholastic Philosophy, which consists mainly of a series of
questions and determinations upon the various points of a certain
technical divinity. Of this kind is the _Book of Sentences_ of Peter
the Lombard (bishop of Paris), who is, on that account, usually
called "Magister Sententiarum;" a work which was published in the
twelfth century, and was long the text and standard of such
discussions. The questions are decided by the authority of Scripture
and of the Fathers of the Church, and are divided into four Books,
of which the first contains questions concerning God and the
doctrine of the Trinity in particular; the second is concerning the
Creation; the third, concerning Christ and the Christian Religion;
and the fourth treats of Religious and Moral Duties. In the second
book, as in many of the writers of this time, the nature of Angels
is considered in detail, and the Orders of their Hierarchy, of which
there were held to be nine. The physical discussions enter only as
bearing upon the scriptural history of the creation, and cannot be
taken as a specimen of the work; but I may observe, that in speaking
of the division of the waters above the {232} firmament, he gives
one opinion, that of Bede, that the former waters are the solid
crystalline heavens in which the stars are fixed,[73\4] "for
crystal, which is so hard and transparent, is made of water." But he
mentions also the opinion of St. Augustine, that the waters above
the heavens are in a state of vapor, (_vaporaliter_) and in minute
drops; "if, then, water can, as we see in clouds, be so minutely
divided that it may be thus supported as vapor on air, which is
naturally lighter than water; why may we not believe that it floats
above that lighter celestial element in still minuter drops and
still lighter vapors? But in whatever manner the waters are there,
we do not doubt that they are there."
[Note 73\4: Lib. ii. Distinct. xiv. _De opere secundæ diei_.]
The celebrated _Summa Theologicæ_ of Thomas Aquinas is a work of the
same kind; and anything which has a physical bearing forms an
equally small part of it. Thus, of the 512 Questions of the _Summa_,
there is only one (Part I., Quest. 115), "on Corporeal Action," or
on any part of the material world; though there are several
concerning the celestial Hierarchies, as "on the Act of Angels,"
"on the Speaking of Angels," "on the Subordination of Angels,"
"on Guardian Angels," and the like. This, of course, would not be
remarkable in a treatise on Theology, except this Theology were
intended to constitute the whole of Philosophy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account