History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
In the first place, the meaning which any generation puts upon the
phrases of Scripture, depends, more than is at first sight supposed
upon the received philosophy of the time. Hence, while men imagine
that they are contending for Revelation, they are, in fact,
contending for their own interpretation of Revelation, unconsciously
adapted to what they believe to be rationally probable. And the new
interpretation, which the new philosophy requires, and which appears
to the older school to be a fatal violence done to the authority of
religion, is accepted by their successors without the dangerous
results which were apprehended. When the language of Scripture,
invested with its new meaning, has become familiar to men, it is
found that the ideas which it calls up, are quite as reconcilable as
the former ones were with the soundest religious views. And the
world then looks back with surprise at the error of those who
thought that the essence of Revelation was involved in their own
arbitrary version of some collateral circumstance. At the present
day we can hardly conceive how reasonable men should have imagined
that religious reflections on the stability of the earth, and the
beauty and use of the luminaries which revolve round it, would be
interfered with by its being acknowledged that this rest and motion
are apparent only.
In the next place, we may observe that those who thus adhere
tenaciously to the traditionary or arbitrary mode of understanding
Scriptural expressions of physical events, are always strongly
condemned by succeeding generations. They are looked upon with
contempt by the world at large, who cannot enter into the obsolete
difficulties with which they encumbered themselves; and with pity by
the more considerate and serious, who know how much sagacity and
rightmindedness are requisite for the conduct of philosophers and
religious men on such occasions; but who know also how weak and vain
is the attempt {287} to get rid of the difficulty by merely
denouncing the new tenets as inconsistent with religious belief, and
by visiting the promulgators of them with severity such as the state
of opinions and institutions may allow. The prosecutors of Galileo
are still up to the scorn and aversion of mankind: although, as we
have seen, they did not act till it seemed that their position
compelled them to do so, and then proceeded with all the gentleness
and moderation which were compatible with judicial forms.
_Sect._ 5.--_The Heliocentric Theory confirmed on Physical
considerations.--_(_Prelude to Kepler's Astronomical Discoveries._)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account