History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
One of the doctrines which was the subject of the warmest discussion
between the defenders and opposers of Aristotle, at the revival of
physical knowledge, was that in which he asserts,[28\1] "That body
is heavier than another which in an equal bulk moves downward
quicker." The opinion maintained by the **Aristotelians at the time of
Galileo was, that bodies fall quicker exactly in proportion to their
weight. The master himself asserts this in express terms, and
reasons upon it.[29\1] Yet in another passage he appears to
distinguish between weight and actual motion downwards.[30\1] "In
physics, we call bodies heavy and light from their _power_ of
motion; but these names are not applied to their actual operations
(ἐνέργειαις) except any one thinks {72} _momentum_ (ῥοπὴ) to be a
word of both applications. But heavy and light are, as it were, the
_embers_ or _sparks_ of motion, and therefore proper to be treated
of here."
[Note 28\1: De Cœlo, iv. 1, p. 308.]
[Note 29\1: Ib. iii. 2.]
[Note 30\1: Ib. iv. 1, p. 307.]
The distinction just alluded to, between Power or Faculty of Action,
and actual Operation or Energy, is one very frequently referred to
by Aristotle; and though not by any means useless, may easily be so
used as to lead to mere verbal refinements instead of substantial
knowledge.
The Aristotelian distinction of Causes has not any very immediate
bearing upon the parts of physics of which we have here mainly
spoken; but it was so extensively accepted, and so long retained,
that it may be proper to notice it.[31\1] "One kind of Cause is the
matter of which any thing is made, as bronze of a statue, and silver
of a vial; another is the form and pattern, as the Cause of an
octave is the ratio of two to one; again, there is the Cause which
is the origin of the production, as the father of the child; and
again, there is the End, or that for the sake of which any thing is
done, as health is the cause of walking." These four kinds of Cause,
the _material_, the _formal_, the _efficient_, and the _final_, were
long leading points in all speculative inquiries; and our familiar
forms of speech still retain traces of the influence of this
division.
[Note 31\1: Phys. ii. 3.]
It is my object here to present to the reader in an intelligible
shape, the principles and mode of reasoning of the Aristotelian
philosophy, not its results. If this were not the case, it would be
easy to excite a smile by insulating some of the passages which are
most remote from modern notions. I will only mention, as specimens,
two such passages, both very remarkable.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account