History of the Jews in Russia and Poland, Volume 1 [of 3]: From the Beginning until the Death of Alexander I (1825)Dubnow, Simon
History
History of the Jews in Russia and Poland, Volume 1 [of 3]: From the Beginning until the Death of Alexander I (1825)
Dubnow, Simon
Jews -- Poland -- History; Jews -- Russia -- History; Poland -- History; Russia -- History
The whole instruction at the yeshibah--writes the well-known
preacher Solomon Ephraim of Lenchitza (d. 1619)[85]--reduces
itself to mental equilibristics and empty argumentations called
hilluk. It is dreadful to contemplate that some venerable rabbi,
presiding over a yeshibah, in his anxiety to discover and
communicate to others some new interpretation, should offer a
perverted explanation of the Talmud, though he himself and every
one else be fully aware that the true meaning is different. Can
it be God's will that we sharpen our minds by fallacies and
sophistries, spending our time in vain and teaching the
listeners to do likewise? And all this for the mere ambition of
passing for a great scholar!... I myself have more than once
argued with the Talmudic celebrities of our time, showing the
need for abolishing the method of pilpul and hilluk, without
being able to convince them. This attitude can only be explained
by the eagerness of these scholars for honors and rosh-yeshibah
posts. These empty quibbles have a particularly pernicious
effect on our bahurs, for the reason that the bahur who does not
shine in the discussion is looked down upon as incapable, and is
practically forced to lay aside his studies, though he might
prove to be one of the best, if Bible, Mishnah, Talmud, and the
Codes were studied in a regular fashion. I myself have known
capable young men who, not having distinguished themselves in
pilpul, forfeited the respect of their fellow-students, and
stopped studying altogether after their marriage.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account