History of the Origin of Representative Government in EuropeGuizot, François
History
History of the Origin of Representative Government in Europe
Guizot, François
Europe -- History; Representative government and representation
We may, if I mistake not, reduce to three the conditions
necessary, and the forms essential, to the representative system;
all three are perhaps not equally necessary; their simultaneous
existence is not perhaps indispensable in order to indicate the
existence and secure the development of the principle from which
they are derived. We may, however, justly consider them as
fundamental. These forms are: 1st. The division of powers; 2nd.
Election; 3rd. Publicity.
We have seen that no really existing power can be a rightful
power, except in so far as it acts according to reason and truth,
the only legitimate rule of action, the only source of right.
No existing power can fully know and constantly regard the
guidance of reason and truth according to which it is bound to
regulate its action. No actual power then is, or can be, in
itself, a power by inherent right. In other words, as no existing
power can be found that is infallible, there is none that may
retain its existence on the tenure of absolute right.
Such is, however, the condition of human things that they need,
as a last appeal, the intervention of a power which may declare
the law to be the rule of government, and which shall impose it
and cause it to be respected. In all the relations which the
social state admits and to which it gives birth, from domestic
order to political order, the presence of a power which may give
and maintain the rule of action, is a necessary condition of the
very existence of society.
{78}
We see then the dilemma in which society is placed. No actual
power can vindicate a claim to become an absolute power; hence
the necessity, in order to meet particular emergencies, of a
power that is definite, that is to say, _actually_ absolute.
Problem Of Government.
The problem of government is--how to give society a guarantee
that the power, which is in operation absolute, to which all
social relations must necessarily be referred, shall be but the
image, the expression, the organ of that power which is
rightfully absolute and alone legitimate, and which is never to
be found localized in this world? This is also, as we have seen,
the problem which the representative system formally proposes to
itself, since all its arrangements assume the existence of this
problem and are framed with a purpose to resolve it.
To make actual power, as far as possible, identical with rightful
power, by imposing upon it the abiding necessity of seeking for
reason, truth, and justice--the sources of right; by investing it
with practical power only when it has proved, that is to say,
given a presumption of, its success in this search; and by
compelling it ever to renew and confirm this presumption under
penalty of losing power if it is unable to do so, this is the
course of the representative system,--this is the end at which it
aims and according to which it directs, in their relations and
their movement, all the resources which it brings into action.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account