History of Zionism, 1600-1918, Vol. 1 (of 2)Sokolow, Nahum
History
History of Zionism, 1600-1918, Vol. 1 (of 2)
Sokolow, Nahum
Jews -- Restoration; Zionism -- History
² _The Times_ reported on the 17th January, 1807, from Warsaw,
the capital of Poland: “It is stated, that there are no
less than nine thousand _Jews_ in Warsaw. BUONAPARTE will
very probably confer on them the privilege of sending their
Representatives to the Jewish Sanhedrim, at Paris. At all
events, it is likely that his _Corsican Majesty_ will have
some business to settle with them. [Baron Alexander _de_]
Talleyrand (1776‒1839) is going there, and will want
_beaucoup d’argent_.”
³ Collection des Procès-Verbaux et Décisions du Grand
Sanhedrin,... Publiée par _M._ Diogène Tama. Paris ... 1807.
[B. M.]
Some historians have been inclined to regard the Paris _Sanhedrin_ as
a denial of Jewish nationality. This view is wrong, and no conception
of history could be more contrary to the facts. A careful study of the
literature of that time will show that the _Sanhedrin_ was inspired by
traditional Jewish ideas. One of the most prominent French Jews, who
was the first Jew to practise in France as a barrister, _M._ Michael
Berr, had sent a request to all princes and nations “to release the
Jews from bondage.” Another member of the _Sanhedrin_, _M._ Lipman
Cerf-Berr (1760‒1831), said in his public speech: “Let us forget our
origin! Let us no longer speak of Jews of Alsace, of Portugal, or of
Germany! Though scattered over the face of the earth, we are still
_one people, worshipping the same God_, and as our law commands, we
are to obey the laws of the country in which we live.”¹ This is not
the language of men who aim at assimilation and the disintegration of
their nationality. The ideas of these men are not to be confused with
what modern Jewish assimilation preaches. Modern Jewish assimilation
denies and rejects all Jewish “separatism” except on the religious
side. Consequently, it would not allow the Jew the right to forget
that he was in Alsace, in Portugal, and so on. According to the
assimilation doctrine, a Jew must be merely an Alsatian, or a
Portuguese, “of the Jewish persuasion.” The purpose of the _Sanhedrin_
was evidently quite different. The _Sanhedrin_ intended to reconstruct
European Jewry on French imperial lines, with a religious centre in
Paris. It therefore examined, with great care and minuteness, those
passages in the Bible and the _Talmud_ which showed that the general
laws of the Empire were binding on the Jews. On these premises was
based a declaration of loyalty given by united Jewry, and sanctioned
by the revival of the _Sanhedrin_, an ancient national institution.
¹ Collection des Actes de l’Assemblée des Israélites de France
et du royaume d’Italie,... Publiée par M. Diogène Tama.
Paris,... 1807 [B. M.] _pp._: 71, 124, 157, 158.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account