History of Zionism, 1600-1918, Vol. 1 (of 2)Sokolow, Nahum
History
History of Zionism, 1600-1918, Vol. 1 (of 2)
Sokolow, Nahum
Jews -- Restoration; Zionism -- History
the national culture, religion and traditions of the Jews, which are
endangered by assimilation. The question of bread, important as it
is, is not the whole of the Jewish problem. The old Roman “panem et
circenses” could never become a Jewish principle. The Jewish principle
is expressed in the words:――
“... man doth not live by bread only, but by everything
that proceedeth out of the mouth of the Lord doth man live”
(Deuteronomy viii. 3).
Now members of other nations can find a home in America while their
nation remains and develops its own life in the mother-country. But
where is the mother-country of the Jews, of Judaism?
Various schemes of Jewish colonisation were planned and partly carried
out in America at the time of which we speak. Some of them met with
some success, others proved utter failures. On the other hand, great
masses of Jews were inspired by the conviction that good results could
be expected only in Palestine from an effort to turn the exiled Jews
into agriculturists. That view was strongly opposed by others who,
living themselves in affluence, thought that they would always be
secure against persecution in the countries in which they dwelt. They
consequently thought that the Jewish problem could be solved only by
a real union between the Jews and their non-Jewish neighbours, by a
process in which the Jews would cast off all that separated them from
non-Jews. They were blind to the fact, established by the whole of
Jewish history, that the more the Jew denies his distinctiveness the
more he is attacked and accused of it; and that whilst small groups of
Jews may sometimes succeed in getting rid of their dissimilarity, the
Jewish masses neither can nor will. They thought that Palestine should
be the last place for the Jew of to-day to think of, being under the
mistaken impression that the Holy Land was unsuitable for colonisation
and agriculture on a large scale. They argued from a technical
standpoint which had a bad foundation. They had no knowledge of the
facts, and Palestine was for them really a _terra incognita_. But
the masses turned with a unanimous impulse to Palestine. Everywhere
societies of “Lovers of _Zion_” were founded for the realization
of the cherished hope of making Jews once more owners of land in
Palestine. Sometimes the idea was taken up with more enthusiasm than
practical sense, and many hurried to Palestine in the belief that,
once in the country, they would find it easy to make a living. Not
unnaturally there was much disillusionment, and many a bitter lesson
was learnt by sad experience. So it became incumbent upon the existing
societies to keep the enthusiasm of their adherents within the bounds
of sanity and practicability. The societies had to grope their way
carefully. They had to find out suitable localities for establishing
colonies, to direct the energies of those most fit to undertake
colonising work into the proper channels, and to check the efforts of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account