Homer's Odyssey: A CommentarySnider, Denton Jaques
Philosophy
Homer's Odyssey: A Commentary
Snider, Denton Jaques
Epic poetry, Greek -- History and criticism; Homer. Odyssey; Odysseus, King of Ithaca (Mythological character) -- In literature
The three songs of the bard furnish the main landmarks for the organism
of the Book. All of them will be found more or less intimately
connected with the great event of the immediate Past, the story of
Troy. Phaeacia shows an intense interest in that story and the bard
approves himself its worthy singer. Indeed the three songs stand in
direct relation to the Iliad; the first deals with an event antecedent
to the Iliad; the second has the theme of the Iliad, though in a
changed form, inasmuch as the seducer, the wife and the husband are
here Gods (Mars, Venus, Vulcan) instead of mortals (Paris, Helen,
Menelaus); the third deals with an event subsequent to the Iliad. Yet
the singer carefully avoids repeating anything in the Iliad. It is
almost impossible not to think that he had not that poem in mind; or,
rather, we are forced to conclude that the present author of the
Odyssey knew the Iliad, and we naturally think that both were by the
same man. Demodocus is the singer of the Trojan War, yet he shuns
singing what has already been sung about it. Herein we may catch
another faint reflection of Homer, the organizer, the transfigurer of
old legends into his two poems. Note also that he hovers around the
Iliad, before and after it, yet never into it, here and elsewhere in
the Odyssey; specially in the Third Book have we observed the same
fact.
In the present Book, however, is another strand; besides these songs of
the bard belonging to the past are the doings in Phaeacia belonging to
the present, which doings have a connection and a correspondence with
the songs. Thus we observe three divisions in the Book, and two threads
which run through these divisions. The following outline may serve to
show the general structure:--
I. There is the representation of the struggle between the physical and
mental in what may be called Phaeacian art; skill and strength have an
encounter shown in two ways:
1. Past, heroic, ideal; the contest between Ulysses and Achilles at
Troy; intelligence vs. mere courage. Sung by the bard. Pre-Iliad.
2. Present, real, not heroic; the games in which there is a contest
also, and in which both skill and strength are involved, with the
preponderance of the physical.
II. Now we drop to the sensuous inactive side of the Phaeacian world,
the luxurious, self-indulgent phase of their life, which is also imaged
in their art doubly:
1. Past; an Olympian episode, a story of illicit love among the
Gods, corresponding to the story of Helen on earth. Sung by the
bard.
2. Present; hints concerning the sensuous life of the Phaeacians who
love the feast, the song, the warm bath and bed, along with dance
and music, showing their pleasure in art. Return of the men from
the market-place to the palace and into the presence of Arete.
III. We pass to what may be called the triumph of intelligence and the
recognition thereof,--Phaeacian art is again introduced, Ulysses is
revealed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account