Humanism and America : $b Essays on the outlook of modern civilisation
Philosophy
Humanism and America : $b Essays on the outlook of modern civilisation
Humanism; Literature -- Philosophy; Philosophy, Modern; United States -- Civilization -- 20th century
But so deep-going an alteration in human nature, such a huge
discrepancy between present and past, is disconcerting to the mind.
It must needs be reduced and accounted for. Our emotional conviction
of the obsolescence of pride, like every other strong and persistent
feeling harboured by human beings, must needs be rationalised. And the
rationalisation is now in progress. Pride has seemed to our imagination
very unreal in the present; therefore our reason is demonstrating that
it was also quite unreal in the past. Historical science aided by other
sciences has undermined the pride of the past. It appears now that
proud princes, as well as proud nations and empires, fell of old not by
reason of pride but by reason of economics--or the lack of economics.
Or else there were geographical, ethnological, biological, or
psychological causes. The last-mentioned category is the most effective
of all for eliminating moral factors from human history. For example,
only an old-fashioned reader may still fancy that Henry the Second,
by conquering the violence of his pride, could have refrained from
causing the slaughter of Becket. That, to be sure, was the subsequent
opinion of Henry himself. But, psychologically speaking, Henry and the
old-fashioned reader are mistaken. Henry was subject to certain stimuli
and certain complexes that completely determined, and completely
explain, his extraordinary behaviour before and after the murder of the
archbishop.
Emerson, looking back mildly from Concord upon the greedy and murderous
pride of old days, found human history very tiresome because it was
so very bad. To-day many disillusioned persons are finding it still
more tiresome because it seems to them neither bad nor good. It is
non-moral, and therefore non-dramatic. Never does it hang dramatically
in the fearful balance of the free human will between a false pride and
a right humility. It merely moves back and forth like the waves and
currents of the sea. History, unhappily, just happens.
Perhaps, however, this ultra-modern view of history, in which pride
seems so unreal, is itself the offspring of a very real pride. Modern
pride is not of necessity less real than ancient pride just because, so
far, its way is less conscious and dramatic. After all it takes time
to dramatise ourselves to ourselves; and the modern age, so modernists
say, is not yet in full swing. They say that the modern theatre has
merely made a beginning and that in the future it will do great things.
If so, I would claim that the greatest of those great things must be an
adequate dramatisation of modern pride. But we cannot wait for that.
If we did, it would never come. It cannot come until there is general
recognition of the fact that pride is still the grand protagonist in
the human drama; and that under its drab modern dress it has lost not a
whit of its ancient sinew.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account