Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the EarthPlayfair, John
Science
Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth
Playfair, John
Geology; Hutton, James, 1726-1797. Theory of the earth
271. Notwithstanding all this accumulated and unanswerable evidence
for the igneous formation of basaltes, a great objection would still
remain to our theory, were it not for the very accurate and conclusive
experiments concerning the fusion of this fossil, referred to above, §
75. A strong prejudice against the production of any thing like a real
stone by means of fusion, had arisen, even among those mineralogists,
who were every day witnesses of the stony appearance assumed by
volcanic lava. They still maintained, on the authority of their own
imperfect experiments, that nothing but glass can ever be obtained
by the melting of earths or of stones, in whatever manner they are
combined.
An ingenious naturalist, after describing a block of basaltes, in which
he discovered such appearances, as inclined him to admit its igneous
consolidation, rejects that hypothesis, merely from the imaginary
inability of fire to give to any substance a stony character: "Quelque
mélange,"says he, "de terres que l'on suppose, quelque soit le degré
de feu que l'on imagine, quelque soit le tems que l'on emploie, il est
très certain que l'on n'obtiendra pas, par le seul fluide igné, ni
basalte, ni rien qui lui ressemble."[138]
[Footnote 138: Journal de Phys. tom. xlix. (1799,) p. 36.]
Sir James Hall's experiments have completely demonstrated the contrary
of what is here asserted: they have added much to the evidence of the
Huttonian system; and, independently of all theory, have narrowed the
circle of prejudice and error.
NOTE XV. § 83.
_On Granite._
1. _Granite Veins._
272. It is said above, § 77, that granite is found in unstratified
masses, and in veins. In the former of these conditions, it constitutes
entire mountains, and forms the central ridge of many of the greatest
chains that traverse the surface of the earth. It is the granite of
this kind that has been most generally described by travellers and
mineralogists. The veins have not been so much attended to, though
they are of peculiar importance for ascertaining the relation between
granite and other fossils.
273. Though Dr Hutton was the first geologist who explained the nature
of granite veins, and who observed with attention the phenomena
which accompany them, he is not the first who has mentioned them. M.
Besson found veins of this kind in the Limoges, in an argillaceous
schistus, and unconnected, as far as appeared, with any large mass of
granite.[139]
[Footnote 139: Journal de Phys. tom. xxix. p. 89.]
Saussure met with granite veins in the Valorsine, but did not see them
distinctly. He ascribed them to infiltration.[140] The date of this
observation is in 1776: He afterwards discovered similar appearances at
Lyons.[141]
[Footnote 140: Voyage au Alpes, tom. i. § 598, 599.]
[Footnote 141: _Ibid._ § 601.]
Werner also, in enumerating the substances of which veins are formed,
reckons granite as one of them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account