Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the EarthPlayfair, John
Science
Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth
Playfair, John
Geology; Hutton, James, 1726-1797. Theory of the earth
What holds of Siberia and of North America, is applicable, _a
fortiori_, to all the other places where animal remains are found
in the same condition. Thus we are carried back to a time when many
larger species of animals, now entirely extinct, inhabited the earth,
and when varieties of those that are at present confined to particular
situations, were, either by the liberty of migration, or by their
natural constitution, accommodated to all the diversities of climate.
This period, though beyond the limits of ordinary chronology, is
posterior to the great revolutions on the earth's surface, and the
latest among geological epochs.
NOTE XXIII. § 128.
_Geology of_ KIRWAN _and_ DE LUC.
419. The two champions of the Neptunian system, who have distinguished
themselves most by their hostility to Dr HUTTON, are DE LUC and KIRWAN.
They have carried on their attack nearly on the same plan, and have
employed against their antagonist the weapons both of theology and
science. With a spirit as injurious to the dignity of religion, as to
the freedom of philosophical inquiry, they have disregarded a maxim
enforced by the authority of Bacon, and by all our experience of the
past; "_Tanto magis hæc vanitas inhibenda venit et coërcenda, quia,
ex divinorum et humanorum male-sana admixtione, non solum educitur
philosophia phantastica, sed etiam religio hæretica. Itaque salutare
admodum est, si mente sobriâ, fidei tantum dentur quæ fidei sunt_."[228]
[Footnote 228: The whole passage is deserving of attention, and
it seems as if the prophetic spirit of Bacon had addressed it to
the cosmologists of the present day. "_Pessima enim res errorem_
APOTHEOSIS, _et pro peste intellectús habenda est, si vanis accedat
veneratio. Huic autan vanitati nonnulli ex modernis summâ levitate ita
indulserunt, ut, in primo capitolo_ GENESEOS, _et aliis Scripturis
Sacris, philosophiam naturalem fundari conati sunt:_ Inter VIVA
quærentes MORTUA.--"Nov. Organum, lib. i. aphor. 65]
Proceeding, accordingly, in direct opposition to rules that, have never
yet been violated with impunity, and mistaking the true object of a
theory of the earth, they carry back their inquiries to a period prior
to the present series of causes and effects, where, having neither
experience nor analogy to direct them, they pretend to be guided by
a superior light. They would have us to consider their geological
speculations as a commentary on the text of MOSES; they endeavour to
explain the action of creative power, and, with indiscreet curiosity,
would tear off the veil which the hand of the prophet has so wisely
respected. But the veil cannot be torn off, and all that is behind it
must be to man as that which never has existed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account