In the Shadow of DeathKritzinger, P. H. (Pieter Hendrick)
History
In the Shadow of Death
Kritzinger, P. H. (Pieter Hendrick)
South African War, 1899-1902 -- Personal narratives
"During the seventeen months that I have served in South Africa I
had, perhaps, rather exceptional opportunities of learning how our
wounded were treated by the Boers. On two different occasions men
under my command who were dangerously wounded were attended with
the greatest kindness and care by the Boers; and the wounded men
themselves begged me to thank those who had been so good to them.
On both occasions the general in command of the column conveyed his
thanks either personally or by letter. I have spoken to many
officers and men who have been left sick or wounded in the hands of
the Boers, and in no single instance have I heard anything but
gratitude expressed for the treatment they had received. In the
intense excitement of hand-to-hand fighting it may be difficult to
differentiate between the wounded and unwounded, but the relatives
and friends of those now fighting may rest assured that English
left wounded on the field will receive from the Boers no less care
and kindness than wounded Boers have invariably received from the
English."
Such is the testimony of men who came in contact with the Boers at a
time when one would expect that the demoralizing and hardening
influences of war had removed every vestige of gentleness.
We never heard the Boers use strong and abusive language towards
prisoners-of-war. On the contrary they would converse with them in a
most genial and friendly spirit; so much so, that the onlooker could
scarcely distinguish between Boer and Briton, friend or foe. Now when
the Boers behaved thus towards their prisoners-of-war they only did
what they ought to have done. When a man is captured or wounded he is no
more an enemy in the literal sense of the word, and should not be
treated as such. Military precautions must necessarily be taken to
prevent the escape of prisoners, but, apart from that, men forced to
surrender should neither be regarded nor treated as criminals, but as an
honourable foe deserves. In making these remarks we do not infer that
our wounded were not well attended to by the enemy. In most cases we
believe they were. We shall not comment on the treatment extended to our
prisoners-of-war. In the latter stage of the war we believe there was
room for improvement, especially when natives were taken up in the
British ranks. These natives treated our men shamefully at times, and
went even so far as to commit the most brutal murders.
Not only did the burghers treat their prisoners-of-war well, but the
Boer officers under whose immediate control they were placed dealt, as a
rule, very kindly and leniently with them. Some of the more prominent
Boer officers, such as General De Wet and others, have been accused
occasionally of having ill-treated prisoners-of-war. Most of these
charges on examination proved groundless.
Mr. Erskine Childers, in a letter to the _Times_, expressed himself on
this matter as follows:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account