The Extremists would have nothing to do with the English in the
Government or outside; the Moderates consider co-operation with the
English necessary for national development, political, industrial,
economic, and otherwise. The Extremists would straightway assume
full responsibility of Government; the Moderates think that would
lead to chaos, and would proceed by stages. It is the difference
between cataclysm and evolution. The Extremists' ideal is
destruction of the existing order of things in the hope that
something better will take its place, for nothing can be worse than
what is; the Moderates' ideal is formation of a new order of things
on definite progressive lines. One is chance, the other is design.
The primary difference (so far as methods are concerned) is that
the Extremists' method is not necessarily constitutional; the
Moderates' method always constitutional. Some Extremists use
violence, others work secretly and spread discontent and
disaffection. Others again, pretending to follow legitimate methods
of agitation, take care not to discourage unconstitutional methods
or even crimes, nay, they miss no opportunity to applaud criminals
as martyrs. There are others, again, who merely idealise and are
content with rousing the passions of the people. Intrigue and abuse
are the general weapons in the Extremists' armoury. The Moderates
always act openly and with dignity, and follow lawful methods of
agitation. The Extremists always oppose the Government. The
Moderates co-operate with authority, and oppose when necessary in
the interests of the country. Lastly, the Extremists appeal only to
the passions of the people; the Moderates appeal to their reason.
Later developments in India itself were unfortunately to play once more
into the hands of the Extremists, and the leadership was to pass from
Mr. Tilak, who was growing old and died in the summer of 1920, and from
Mrs. Besant too, who, after being bitterly reviled by her former ally,
at last saw the error of her ways and finally went over to the Moderate
camp with the diminishing remnants of her influence, into the hands of a
new and strange figure in Indian politics, Mr. Gandhi, endowed with very
different qualities and greater spiritual influence than either of them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account