Influenza : $b An epidemiologic studyVaughan, Warren T. (Warren Taylor)
History
Influenza : $b An epidemiologic study
Vaughan, Warren T. (Warren Taylor)
Influenza
Armstrong’s survey has also thrown some light on the effect of the
influenza on previously tubercularized individuals. In a survey of 700
individuals who had had the acute disease there were ten arrested cases
of tuberculosis, or 1.4 per cent. All these had been known to be
arrested cases previous to the epidemic, and in none of them did the
disease appear to have been actively and permanently lighted up. Some
had manifested a slight activity, but all seemed to be on the way to a
rearrest of the disease. On the other hand, thirteen cases, or 2 per
cent. of the 700, were found to have active tuberculosis which had
hitherto been undiagnosed, and an additional eight cases, with
indefinite broncho-pulmonary signs, were designated as incipient
tuberculosis cases. This is to be contrasted with an incidence of active
tuberculosis in the pre-epidemic examination of approximately one per
cent. These figures would indicate an increase in tuberculosis
incidence. How may this be explained? The accuracy of these results will
depend on how the 700 cases were selected. If, for example, individuals
who feared tuberculosis because of known exposure, requested
examination, the results might be influenced by their inclusion.
It has long been known that individuals with measles will not react to
tuberculin tests, even though they have been positive before developing
the measles, and though they will become positive again after recovery.
The same may be said of vaccination. Individuals vaccinated against
smallpox, who have measles, and are during their illness revaccinated,
will not show an immediate reaction. The test will remain entirely
negative, while after recovery, the immediate reaction may be obtained.
Normally, it will appear in 95 per cent. of cases, while among those
with measles the phenomenon remains absent in 90 per cent. The same
phenomenon is present in certain other acute illnesses, particularly
scarlet fever. It has been variously explained. von Pirquet, who was the
first to observe it in measles, believed that the acute disease created
a temporary inability to produce antibodies, and therefore designated
the condition by the name “anergie.” The same phenomenon of anergie has
been found recently to hold in the case of influenza. Debré and Jacquet,
Lereboullet, Bloomfield and Mateer, as well as Berliner and Schiffer,
have brought forth abundant evidence to this effect, following the 1918
pandemic. It has also been shown by Cayrel and others that there is a
diminution of typhoid agglutinins in the serum of influenza patients
vaccinated against typhoid. The agglutinin titer again increases after
recovery. It is true that the agglutinin titer is not a measure of
immunity, but it is frequently used as such and serves to give us some
information on the subject. If, then, influenza is an anergic disease, a
“maladie anergisante,” we have a theoretical explanation of the increase
in severity of tuberculosis following the acute infection. We have long
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account