Introduction to the textual criticism of the Greek New TestamentNestle, Eberhard
Religion
Introduction to the textual criticism of the Greek New Testament
Nestle, Eberhard
Bible. New Testament -- Criticism, Textual
i. 34. For υἱὸς א*, Syr^{cu}, Syr^{sin}, and e read ἐκλεκτός. D is here
defective. Zahn thinks the latter reading is original, and the former an
example of an early and widely current alteration. Westcott and Hort
insert ἐκλεκτός among their _Noteworthy Rejected Readings_. The two
readings are combined in some manuscripts “electus filius Dei.” See
Zahn, _Einl._, ii. 515, 544, 557.
i. 41. Zahn here decides for the nominative πρῶτος. Both the disciples
of John who attached themselves to Jesus found their brother, but Andrew
was the first to do so. See _Einleitung_, ii. 477 f.
ii. 2. In his Commentary on the Gospels, extant in the Armenian only, we
find Ephraem saying, “Graecus scribit _recubuit et defecit vinum_” (§
53), which shows that he had a Greek exemplar before him containing the
itacism ἐκλίθη for ἐκλήθη. See Zahn, _Forsch._, i. 62, 127, and compare
Luke xiv. 8, where Antiochus, _Homil._, iii., has κατακλιθῇς for κληθῇς.
ii. 3. Zahn is perhaps right when he says that no critic need doubt for
a moment that the original reading is the longer, genuinely Semitic text
exhibited by א*, the Harklean Syriac, and the best Latin manuscripts. D
is defective, as also Syr^{cu} and Syr^{sin}.
iii. 5. βασιλείαν τῶν οὐρανῶν is attested only by א*, a few minuscules,
by c m, and certain early Fathers, in place of βασιλείαν τοῦ θεοῦ, which
has now the support of the Sinai-Syriac. Zahn thinks the former reading
to be correct (_Einleitung_, ii. 294). If that is so, this will be the
only place where the expression is found in the New Testament outside
the Gospel according to Matthew, where it occurs some thirty-three or
thirty-four times. See note on “The Kingdom of Heaven” in the
_Expository Times_ for February 1896, p. 236 ff.
iii. 24. Zahn (_Einl._, ii. 515) thinks that the omission of the article
before φυλακὴν shows that there was some uncertainty regarding the fact
mentioned by John. This, however, is open to question. That the
insertion or omission of the article may be of importance is shown by
such examples as John v. 1; Matthew xxii. 23; Acts xvi. 6; James ii. 2.
iii. 34. Our knowledge of the text of the Sinai-Syriac here rests solely
on the last reading of Mrs. Lewis: “Not according to his measure gave
(or, gives) God the Father.” This rendering, as well as the insertion of
ὁ Θεός in many Greek texts, is due to the fact that πνεῦμα was not taken
as the subject of the sentence.
iv. 1. For ὁ κύριος Tischendorf reads ὁ Ἰησοῦς, which is probably
correct. Ὁ κύριος is elsewhere found only three times in John—viz., vi.
23, xi. 2, xx. 20. According to Zahn (_Einl._, ii. 391) the first two
passages are explanations outside the Gospel narrative interjected by
the evangelist, while the words in the last passage are spoken from the
point of view of the disciples.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account