After his first attack on MacBrien, Edward Butler wandered away into the King's County. There was a standing dispute between the O'Carrolls and the Butlers, the latter alleging that Ely was part of Tipperary, the former that it belonged to the more lately formed shire and was consequently outside Ormonde's palatinate jurisdiction. Thady O'Carroll, one of the chief's three sons, had married a Galway lady, and on his way towards the Shannon to visit his father-in-law was unlucky enough to come across Edward Butler's band. O'Carroll had but a few men with him, and it is therefore not at all likely that he was the assailant in the skirmish which followed, and in which he was taken prisoner. As to the previous quarrels, which Butler alleged as a reason for keeping armed men, the Lords Justices seem to have thought there was much to be said on both sides, but they charged Butler to appear before them at once, and warned him of the danger of taking the law into his own hands. Sir William O'Carroll was also summoned, but neither were in any hurry to obey, and the matter was quite unsettled when Sidney landed at Carrickfergus.[155] [Illustration: _Vol. II. to face page 17_ IRELAND ABOUT 1570 _London, Longmans & Co._] FOOTNOTES: [134] Weston to the Queen, Oct. 8; Lords Justices to the Queen, Oct. 30; same to Cecil, Oct. 30 and 31; Weston to Cecil, Oct. 8; Earl of Clanricarde to the Queen, Oct. 22. [135] Lords Justices to the Queen, Dec. 12; Thos. Scott to Cecil, Dec. 14 and 21; Queen to Lords Justices, Dec. 24; Lords Justices to Cecil, Nov. 23; Fitzwilliam to Cecil, Nov. 27. The award of Draycott, M. R., Nugent, S. G., and Serjeant Finglas, is printed from a MS. at Kilkenny, in the _Irish Archæological Journal_, 1st series, iii. 341. [136] Memorial by Cecil, Dec. 22, 1567; Indenture between the Queen and O'Connor Sligo, Jan. 20, 1568; the Queen to the Lords Justices, Jan. 25; Hugh O'Donnell to the Lords Justices, March 26. [137] Tirlogh Luineach to the Lords Justices, Nov. 24, 1567; to Piers, Jan. 20, and to Bagenal, Jan. 17, 1568; Bagenal to the Lords Justices, Feb. 5 and Dec. 2, 1567. Tirlogh calls the Campbells Clan Veginbhne and Clan Meginbhne, names which puzzle me. Argyle he calls 'Dominus Machali comes de Argyle.' Terence Danyell to the Lords Justices, Dec. 10, 1567 [138] Gregory's _Western Highlands_, new ed. pp. 203, _sqq._ Sir Nicholas White's conversation with Mary in his letter to Cecil, Feb. 29, 1569 (in Wright's _Queen Elizabeth_); Piers and Maltby to Sidney, Oct. 6, 1567, and to the Lords Justices, Nov. 18 and Dec. 6; the Queen to the Lords Justices, Dec. 10 and 24; Fitzwilliam to the Queen, Jan. 22, 1568; and to Cecil, Dec. 20, 1567. Peace was granted to Sorley Boy on Dec. 20.