Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
For the national note of the Irish language is not peculiar to what
used to be called the Erse language. The whole nation used the tongue
common to both nations with a difference far beyond a dialect. It
is not a difference of accent, but a difference of style; which
is generally a difference of soul. The emphasis, the elision, the
short cuts and sharp endings of speech, show a variety which may be
almost unnoticeable but is none the less untranslatable. It may be
only a little more weight on a word, or an inversion allowable in
English but abounding in Irish; but we can no more copy it than copy
the compactness of the French _on_ or the Latin ablative absolute.
The commonest case of what I mean, for instance, is the locution
that lingers in my mind with an agreeable phrase from one of Mr
Yeats’s stories: ‘Whom I shall yet see upon the hob of hell, and
them screeching.’ It is an idiom that gives the effect of a pointed
postscript, a parting kick or sting in the tail of the sentence, which
is unfathomably national. It is noteworthy and even curious that
quite a crowd of Irishmen, who quoted to me with just admiration the
noble ending of _Kathleen-na-Hulahan_, where the newcomer is asked
if he has seen the old woman who is the tragic type of Ireland going
out, quoted his answer in that form, ‘I did not. But I saw a young
woman, and she walking like a queen.’ I say it is curious, because I
have since been told that in the actual book (which I cannot lay my
hand on at the moment) a more classic English idiom is used. It would
generally be most unwise to alter the diction of such a master of style
as Mr Yeats: though indeed it is possible that he altered it himself,
as he has sometimes done, and not always, I think, for the better.
But whether this form came from himself or from his countrymen, it
was very redolent of his country. And there was something inspiring
in thus seeing, as it were before one’s eyes, literature becoming
legend. But a hundred other examples could be given, even from my own
short experience, of such fine turns of language, nor are the finest
necessarily to be found in literature. It is perfectly true, though
prigs may overwork and snobs underrate the truth, that in a country
like this the peasants can talk like poets. When I was on the wild
coast of Donegal, an old unhappy woman who had starved through the
famines and the evictions, was telling a lady the tales of those times,
and she mentioned quite naturally one that might have come straight
out of times so mystical that we should call them mythical, that some
travellers had met a poor wandering woman with a baby in those great
gray rocky wastes, and asked her who she was. And she answered, ‘I am
the Mother of God, and this is Himself, and He is the boy you will all
be wanting at the last.’
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account