Isabel of Castile and the making of the Spanish nation, 1451-1504Plunket, Ierne L. (Ierne Lifford)
History
Isabel of Castile and the making of the Spanish nation, 1451-1504
Plunket, Ierne L. (Ierne Lifford)
Isabella I, Queen of Spain, 1451-1504; Spain -- History -- Ferdinand and Isabella, 1479-1516
Very different was her attitude when a criminal of Trujillo, on being
hailed for his misdeeds before the royal judges, protested that he had
received the tonsure and therefore he should be tried in the
ecclesiastical courts. To this plea, a trick to which men who had no
intention of taking orders resorted, that they might escape the rigours
of the secular law, the judges paid no heed; whereupon some priests,
relations of the accused, took up arms in his favour. “The Faith,” they
declared, “was in danger of perdition,” and having roused the mob by
inflammatory speeches, they attacked the house of the corregidor and the
local prison. The criminal was released; but the triumph of
ecclesiastical privilege was short-lived; for, some companies of
men-at-arms appearing on the scenes in response to the corregidor’s
appeal to the Queen, the principal lay rioters were hung. The clerical
offenders, saved by their cloth from a like fate, spent the rest of
their days in exile, meditating on the long arm of royal justice.
Equally firm was the position maintained by Ferdinand and Isabel in
their dealings with the Roman See. From one aspect they were sincerely
loyal and devoted to their “Holy Father in Christ,” seeking his sanction
for all those actions where orthodoxy demanded papal consent; and
informing him, in sure confidence of his blessing, of every success they
enjoyed in their struggle with infidels and heretics. The very nature of
the war of Granada earned for them a reputation in Europe as special
champions of the Faith; and, though the honour was prompted rather by
his needs than their deserts, no title could have been more fitting than
“Los Reyes Católicos,” “The Catholic Kings,” bestowed on them by
Alexander VI. in 1494.
Yet, from another point of view, these same “Catholic Kings” were as
staunch opponents of papal encroachments as any imperial Frederick II.
or Henry VIII. of England. It might be said that their disputes with the
Holy Father savoured rather of the spoilt than the rebellious child.
Conscious of their merits as perpetual crusaders and chasteners of the
unorthodox, they preferred, instead of making war on the general
principle of Roman interference in ecclesiastical matters, to demand
exemption as their special right,—the right of those who, with their
ancestors, had won back the soil of their native land in conflict with a
heathen race.
Their hand was none the less iron that it was discreetly gloved. When in
1491 an appeal to Rome was admitted by the Court of Chancery at
Valladolid, in a case falling by law solely within the royal
jurisdiction, Isabel in her indignation did not hesitate to remove all
the judges who had consented to this step, appointing others in their
place.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account