With the publication of the first edition of _The Great Ice Age_ in
1874, Prof. Geikie’s reputation as a glacial geologist of the first
rank was at once established. The book had a cordial reception and a
ready sale. Prof. Green wrote a long and very sympathetic review of
it for _Nature_, and, whether its teachings were generally accepted
or not, the author had the satisfactory proof that it had not been
neglected by the rapid exhaustion of the first edition. Within a few
months he had to set seriously about the production of a new and
enlarged edition. Much of its popularity was no doubt due to the clear
and graceful style in which it was written. The more abstruse parts of
the subject were not discussed with too much detail; great insistence
was placed on the field evidence, and the discussion was such as could
be followed by the general reader who had no special training in
geological work. A studied moderation marked the conclusions arrived
at, and no attempt was made to force a revolutionary interpretation
of glacial phenomena into prominence. A great deal also was due to
the fact that the book embodied not only its author’s work and the
hypotheses he favoured, but also the results of the observations of
many of his colleagues on the Survey who had a very wide acquaintance
with field geology, and were, on the whole, very well agreed regarding
the interpretation of the facts. The author fully acknowledged his
obligations to colleagues on the Survey staff, but at the same time
it was clear that on this subject he was the leader and not merely a
compiler of other people’s results. The dedication to Sir Andrew Ramsay
is especially significant, for from Ramsay more than from any other
geologist had inspiration been received.
Probably the effect of the book was greater in foreign countries
than in Britain. In Germany, Switzerland, Sweden, and the United
States many geologists were actively prosecuting the study of
glacial deposits, and so clear and authoritative a statement of the
observations and conclusions of the Scottish glacialists had much
interest to workers in other lands. This appreciation the author valued
greatly, and it was the cause of a great enlargement in the circle
of his correspondents. He followed keenly the advance of glacial
investigation in foreign countries, and especially the new evidence
brought forward regarding changes of climate during and subsequent to
the glacial period, and the early chapters in the history of man in
Europe.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account