Having already expounded in his previous works the essential phenomena
of glaciation, he devotes this book especially to the consideration
of many questions of subordinate importance, though in themselves
deserving of full consideration. The interglacial problem, of course,
comes up for treatment, but he has not much to say of it that is
really new to his readers. It is interesting to note, however, that
less insistence is now laid on the Scottish evidence in favour of
interglacial periods, and the British evidence in general, and more is
said of the interglacial beds of Germany, France, Italy, Switzerland,
and other European countries. The feeling seems to have arisen in the
author’s mind that much of the British evidence was not so strong as to
carry conviction, and the work of continental geologists was rapidly
adding details of the highest significance to the store of accumulated
observations in favour of repeated glaciations of Northern Europe. We
may readily believe also that he felt it desirable to enforce on the
minds of his readers the value of much recent research done by his
fellow-scientists in other countries. Many British geologists assumed
and still maintain a very sceptical attitude regarding the value of
the British evidence for interglacial periods, and Prof. Geikie was
undoubtedly right in appealing rather to well-established facts in
adjacent countries than attempting to discuss the minutiæ of sections
often of a temporary nature and by no means well-exposed, which were
familiar to many of his British readers. It is not to be supposed,
however, that he had changed his ground; to the last he maintained the
validity of the British evidence for interglacial periods, though in
some parts of it modifications of his original statements might have
become necessary. In the nature of things the evidence collected from
so small an area as Scotland was sure to be incomplete, and to treat
Great Britain as a region apart was more likely to lead to error than
to correct results.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account