Jane Austen, Her Life and Letters: A Family RecordAusten-Leigh, William
General
Jane Austen, Her Life and Letters: A Family Record
Austen-Leigh, William
Austen, Jane, 1775-1817; Austen, Jane, 1775-1817 -- Family; Novelists, English -- 19th century -- Family relationships
The authoress of _Emma_ has no reason, I think, to
complain of her treatment in it, except in the
total omission of _Mansfield Park_. I cannot but
be sorry that so clever a man as the Reviewer of
_Emma_ should consider it as unworthy of being
noticed. You will be pleased to hear that I have
received the Prince's thanks for the _handsome_
copy I sent him of _Emma_. Whatever he may think
of _my_ share of the work, yours seems to have
been quite right.
The fact that she was honoured with a notice in the _Quarterly_ did not
prevent the author from collecting and leaving on record the more
domestic criticisms of her family and friends.
OPINIONS OF _Emma_.
_Captain F. Austen_ liked it extremely, observing
that though there might be more wit in _P. and P._
and an higher morality in _M. P._, yet altogether,
on account of its peculiar air of Nature
throughout, he preferred it to either.
_Mrs. Frank Austen_ liked and admired it very much
indeed, but must still prefer _P. and P._
_Mrs. J. Bridges_ preferred it to all the others.
_Miss Sharp._--Better than _M. P._, but not so
well as _P. and P._ Pleased with the heroine for
her originality, delighted with Mr. K., and called
Mrs. Elton beyond praise--dissatisfied with Jane
Fairfax.
_Cassandra._--Better than _P. and P._ but not so
well as _M. P._
_Fanny K._--Not so well as either _P. and P._ or
_M. P._ Could not bear Emma herself. Mr. Knightley
delightful. Should like J. F. if she knew more of
her.
_Mr. and Mrs. James Austen_ did not like it so
well as either of the three others. Language
different from the others; not so easily read.
_Edward_ preferred it to _M. P._ only. Mr. K.
liked by everybody.
_Miss Bigg._--Not equal to either _P. and P._ or
_M. P._ Objected to the sameness of the subject
(Matchmaking) all through. Too much of Mrs. Elton
and H. Smith. Language superior to the others.
_My Mother_ thought it more entertaining than _M.
P._, but not so interesting as _P. and P._ No
characters in it equal to Lady Catherine or Mr.
Collins.
_Miss Lloyd_ thought it as clever as either of the
others, but did not receive so much pleasure from
it as from _P. and P._ and _M. P._
_Fanny Cage_ liked it very much indeed, and
classed it between _P. and P._ and _M. P._
_Mrs. and Miss Craven_ liked it very much, but not
so much as the others.
_Mr. Sherer_ did not think it equal to either _M.
P._ (which he liked the best of all) or _P. and
P._ Displeased with my pictures of clergymen.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account