"Well, you were wrong there," said Tod. "Yes. But I'm nearly sure I was right in the thing before." "What thing?" demanded old Duff, sharply. "Well, I thought it was Monk that frightened Phoebe." "Oh," said Mr. Duffham. "Dressed himself up in a sheet, and whitened his face, and went up the lane when the women were watching for the shadows on St. Mark's Eve! What else do you suspect, Johnny?" "Nothing else, sir; except that I fancied Mother Picker knew of it. When Tod and I went to ask her whether Monk was out that night, she looked frightened to death, and broke a basin." "Did she say he was out?" "She said he was not out; but I thought she said it more eagerly than truthfully." "Squire, when you are in doubt as to people's morals, let this boy read them for you," said old Duff, in his quaint way. The Squire, thinking of his plants, looked as perplexed as could be. "It is such a thing, you know, Duffham, to have one's whole hothouse destroyed in a night. It's no better than arson." "And the incendiary who did it would have no scruple in attacking the barns next; therefore, he must be bowled out." The pater looked rueful. He could bluster and threaten, but he could not _do_ much; he never knew how to set about it. In all emergencies he would send for Jones--the greatest old woman going. "You don't seriously think it could have been Monk, Duffham?" "I think there's strong suspicion that it was. Look here:" and the doctor began to tell off points with his cane and fingers. "_Somebody_ goes into the greenhouse to set the stuff alight in the pot-stands--for that's how it was done. Monk and Jenkins alone knew where the key was; Jenkins, a trusty man, years in the employ, comes on at six and finds the state of things. Where's Monk? Gone off by previous order to Evesham at five. Why should it happen the very morning he was away? What was to prevent his stealing into the greenhouse after dark last night putting his deleterious stuff to work, leaving it to burn, and stealing in again at four this morning to put all traces away? He thought he cleaned out all the tale-telling earthen saucers, but he overlooks one, as is usually the case. When he comes back, finding the wreck and the commotion consequent upon it, he relates a glib tale of other plants destroyed by arsenic from candles, and he never looks honestly into a single face as he tells it!" The Squire drew a deep breath. "And you say Monk did all this?" "Nonsense, Squire. I say he might have done it. I say, moreover, that it looks very like it. Putting Monk aside, your scent would be wholly at fault." "What is to be done?" "I'll go and see Mother Picker; she can tell what time he went in last night, and what time he came out this morning," cried Tod, who was just as hasty as the pater. But old Duff caught him as he was vaulting off. "_I_ had better see Mother Picker. Will you let me act in this matter, Squire, and see what can be made of it?"