Kentucky's Famous Feuds and Tragedies: Authentic History of the World Renowned Vendettas of the Dark and Bloody GroundMutzenberg, Charles Gustavus
History
Kentucky's Famous Feuds and Tragedies: Authentic History of the World Renowned Vendettas of the Dark and Bloody Ground
Mutzenberg, Charles Gustavus
Crime -- Kentucky; Vendetta -- Kentucky
You seem to charge that I have aided and abetted criminal classes
by declining to place troops at your disposal in Breathitt County,
and attribute to their absence the non-conviction of criminals. If
their absence produced such a result in Breathitt County, their
presence at your court in Perry County should have produced,
according to your logic, a large number of convictions. But I am
advised that the result was the same in both counties. We must,
therefore, look for some other reason than the presence or absence
of the military to account for such uniformity of results. I
believe myself that the court is and ought to be, an important
factor in the administration of justice, and that the presence or
absence of the military should have no weight in its decisions, and
ought not to influence its actions.
You ask why I throw "the whole responsibility" of making an
application for troops upon you? It was because you were the judge
who made the application; who demanded protection, and averred you
would not hold court unless I sent guards along. There was no one
else with whom the responsibility could be divided, and as you must
have acted from your convictions of duty, I do not see why you
should seek to avoid the responsibility, or desire me to place it
where it does not belong.
I have no criticisms to make in reference to other judges who have
asked for troops, or in reference to Judge Finley, who, you say,
failed to attend certain courts.
These were occurrences under former administrations, and were
doubtless considered by the Executives of the time in the light
of facts, which I do not pretend to know. Much less will I offer
my comment upon the grave charges you insinuate against another
judicial officer in connection with the Breathitt court. But I
cannot refrain from expressing regret at what seems to be the
manifestation of feeling on your part, which does not impress me
as strictly judicial, but, notwithstanding this, I beg you to rest
assured of my desire to support your authority in every way that
the Executive can do, consistent with the public welfare. I have no
objection to your giving the fullest publicity to your letter.
Respectfully yours,
S. B. BUCKNER.
The last feud in Breathitt County, during which the most horrible
assassinations were committed, was the Hargis-Cockrell-Marcum-Callahan
vendetta.
The Hargises and the Cockrells claimed that the name is a misnomer--that
no feud existed.
Capulet once said: "The Montagues are furnishing all the trouble and we
are only innocents slaughtered."
Montague said: "The Capulets are making the war. We are only defending
our lives and property."
An apt quotation, here.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account