Animal welfare; Hunting -- Moral and ethical aspects; Hunting -- Religious aspects
But when we turn to the assertion that the practice of sport is,
actually, the best _training_ for war, we find it to be contradicted
by facts. On this point we cannot do better than quote from a letter
addressed to the _Humanitarian_ by Mr. R. B. Cunninghame-Graham:
“The rise of Japan and the fighting qualities of the Japanese
have shaken sportsmen from their ‘sport-the-image-of-war’
position. It is well known that not only are the majority of
Japanese vegetarians, but that such a thing as a sportsman is
unknown amongst them. Yet, without wishing to disparage the
prowess of European soldiers, how many ‘sportsmen’ would wager
much money on the chances of a thousand picked Europeans if
opposed to a thousand Japanese soldiers in an open plain with
no weapons but swords?
“The Boer War, and the miserable figure cut by our officers in
comparison with the Boer officers in both shooting and riding,
disposed conclusively of the ‘sport-the-preparation-for-war’
argument, so dear to sportsmen. In fact, ‘sport’ as understood
in England cannot prepare men for war, even if they ride to
hounds three days a week, shoot the other three, and read the
_Pink Un_ on Sunday. English sport and war are different in
their essence, and one has no analogy to the other.
“In the one case men rise from a comfortable bed, bathe, and
breakfast, and even if they are exposed to weather during the
day, return at night to a well-cooked dinner and comfortable
bed. The horses they ride are valuable, highly-trained animals,
who are expected to put out their full strength for at most
two or three hours, and are perhaps not required again for two
or three days, or even expected to be required. The shooting
is done under the same conditions, and though requiring skill
(as does the riding in fox-hunting), is not of a nature to be
useful in war.
“In neither case does the ‘diversion’ conduce to the
self-denying or abstemious habits so essential in war. Of
course, I do not mean that sportsmen are of necessity of
intemperate habits, but in war the conditions are different
from those of sport. In the latter case the soldier rises,
perhaps from a night of rain round a camp-fire, gets, without
breakfast, on his half-starving horse, and jogs along all day
at a footspace, to sleep, supposing there is no fighting and he
has not been killed, once more by a camp-fire, perhaps again in
rain, or in a driving wind.
“Every condition under which the sportsman plays is different
from those under which the soldier works. As in the Roman times
regiments of gladiators proved the most useless at the front,
so I believe a regiment all composed of sportsmen would make a
miserable show before a thousand quite unsporting Japanese.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account