Lavengro: The Scholar, the Gypsy, the PriestBorrow, George
General
Lavengro: The Scholar, the Gypsy, the Priest
Borrow, George
England -- Fiction; Romanies -- Fiction
I compiled the Chronicles of Newgate; I reviewed books for the Review
established on an entirely new principle; and I occasionally tried my
best to translate into German portions of the publisher's philosophy. In
this last task I experienced more than one difficulty. I was a tolerable
German scholar, it is true, and I had long been able to translate from
German into English with considerable facility; but to translate from a
foreign language into your own is a widely different thing from
translating from your own into a foreign language; and, in my first
attempt to render the publisher into German, I was conscious of making
miserable failures, from pure ignorance of German grammar; however, by
the assistance of grammars and dictionaries, and by extreme perseverance,
I at length overcame all the difficulties connected with the German
language. But, alas! another difficulty remained, far greater than any
connected with German--a difficulty connected with the language of the
publisher--the language which the great man employed in his writings was
very hard to understand; I say in his writings--for his colloquial
English was plain enough. Though not professing to be a scholar, he was
much addicted, when writing, to the use of Greek and Latin terms, not as
other people used them, but in a manner of his own, which set the
authority of dictionaries at defiance; the consequence was that I was
sometimes utterly at a loss to understand the meaning of the publisher.
Many a quarter of an hour did I pass at this period, staring at periods
of the publisher, and wondering what he could mean, but in vain, till at
last, with a shake of the head, I would snatch up the pen, and render the
publisher literally into German. Sometimes I was almost tempted to
substitute something of my own for what the publisher had written, but my
conscience interposed; the awful words, Traduttore traditore, commenced
ringing in my ears, and I asked myself whether I should be acting
honourably towards the publisher, who had committed to me the delicate
task of translating him into German; should I be acting honourably
towards him, in making him speak in German in a manner different from
that in which he expressed himself in English? No, I could not reconcile
such conduct with any principle of honour; by substituting something of
my own in lieu of these mysterious passages of the publisher, I might be
giving a fatal blow to his whole system of philosophy. Besides, when
translating into English, had I treated foreign authors in this manner?
Had I treated the minstrels of the Kaempe Viser in this manner?--No. Had
I treated Ab Gwilym in this manner? Even when translating his Ode to the
Mist, in which he is misty enough, had I attempted to make Ab Gwilym less
misty? No; on referring to my translation, I found that Ab Gwilym in my
hands was quite as misty as in his own. Then, seeing that I had not
ventured to take liberties with people who had never put themselves into
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account