Leaders of the People: Studies in Democratic HistoryClayton, Joseph
History
Leaders of the People: Studies in Democratic History
Clayton, Joseph
Democracy; Great Britain -- History
The ideas of the French Encyclopædists, the writings of Rousseau, and
the revolt of the American colonists, had aroused a belief in social
equality, and the “natural” rights of man, and this belief Cartwright
championed till his death. His early pamphlets, beginning with
“Legislative Rights of the Commonalty Vindicated,” (1777) are heavy
reading to-day, but in them Cartwright argued for all the famous “six
points” of the People’s Charter of fifty years later--Universal Manhood
Suffrage, Annual Parliaments, Vote by Ballot, Abolition of Property
Qualification for Parliamentary Candidates, Payment of Members, and
Equal Electoral Districts. He even uses the modern phrase in urging
“one man one vote.”
Unlike Thomas Paine, and many of the “Radical Reformers,” Cartwright
pleads for political democracy as the natural outcome of the Christian
faith, maintaining that “No man can have a right sense and belief
of Christianity who denies the equality of all conditions of men.”
Incidentally, challenged on the point of why not Votes for Women?
Cartwright could only fall back on certain passages in the Bible to
justify his objection to Women’s Enfranchisement. Nothing was more
abhorrent to his mind than the notion that government was a matter
for “experts,” an exclusive affair for persons with specially trained
intelligences. “Of all the errors to which mankind have ever submitted
their understandings,” he wrote, “there is no one to be more lamented
than that of conceiving the business of civil government to be above
the comprehension of ordinary capacities.”
The poor, because of their very poverty, had a need for the vote and
for parliamentary representation which the man of property could not
experience. This Cartwright emphasised in a petition he presented to
the House of Commons as late as 1820:
And when your Honourable House shall further consider that the
humblest mortal on earth is equally a co-heir of an immortality
with the most exalted who now wears stars, or coronets, or
crowns, your petitioner hopes that your Honourable House
will rise superior to the mean thoughts and vulgar prejudices
of the uncharitable among the wealthy, the ignorant, the
interested, the vain, and the proud; and will acknowledge
that, in reference to the respective claims of legislative
representation by the poor and the rich, the poor have equal
right but far more need.
Enthusiasm and an entirely disinterested zeal for democracy kept
the spirit of youth in Cartwright, and carried him at the age of
80 over a trial for sedition undisturbed. His zeal was not to be
quenched. “Moderation in practice may be commendable,” he declared,
“but moderation in principle is detestable. Can we trust a man who is
moderately honest, or esteem a woman who is moderately virtuous?”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account