Lectures on ancient ethnography and geography, volume 2 (of 2) : $b comprising Greece and her colonies, Epirus, Macedonia, Illyricum, Italy, Gaul, Spain, Britain, the north of Africa, etc.Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
History
Lectures on ancient ethnography and geography, volume 2 (of 2) : $b comprising Greece and her colonies, Epirus, Macedonia, Illyricum, Italy, Gaul, Spain, Britain, the north of Africa, etc.
Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
Ethnology; Geography, Ancient; History, Ancient
be discovered between the Etruscan and the Ligurian language.
The ancients were far less concerned about the Etruscans than the
moderns; they took indeed an interest in them, but did not enter deeply
into the inquiry about them; and it may be that they were prevented by
their utter ignorance of the Etruscan language. Herodotus relates that
the Etruscans were a Lydian colony, a statement which has been correctly
refuted even by Dionysius, who says that Xanthus the Lydian did not
say anything about it; that the Lydians did not bear the slightest
resemblance to the Etruscans in language, customs, manners, or religion;
and that there existed no traditions about such a colony either among the
Lydians or among the Etruscans. Herodotus had heard, that Tyrrhenians
existed in Italy as well as in Lydia (where, however, the Meonians,
and not the entirely foreign Lydians, were Tyrrhenians); his idea of a
colony was a mere inference from his knowledge that the Tyrrhenians and
Meonians were nations of the same race. But Tyrrheni and Tusci are the
same words, and so are Tyrrheni, Turini, Turni; Tusculum is nothing but
the town of the Tyrrheni; Etrusci and Tusci, however, are different, and
the name Tusci was afterwards transferred to the Etrusci. The native name
of the Etruscans was Rasena. Previously to the Gallic conquest, the same
Etruscan nation was also established in the plains of Lombardy; and,
according to Livy, all the tribes about the river Padus, such as the
Raeti and others belonged to it. It is, moreover, quite in accordance
with all analogy to suppose that the nation had come down from the Alps
in consequence of commotions in the north. Here we must also bear in mind
the other tradition which states that, before the time of the Etruscans,
the Umbrians dwelt in Etruria, and that 300 Umbrian towns were destroyed
by the invading Etruscans. No importance can be attached to the number
300, which is only a multiple of 3; 3, 30, 300, and 600, all signify only
“very many,” and in other circumstances the same might be expressed by
4, 16, 64, etc. I am persuaded that the time is not far distant (it may
have arrived already), when no man will think of quoting the statement
of Herodotus about the Lydian origin of the Tyrrhenians as an authority
against other opinions. Everything which, after the lapse of hundreds or
thousands of years, has to be made out by reason and argument meets with
opposition, and this is in accordance with nature; nay, it is good that
it is so, as it imposes upon us the duty to give to our doctrines the
greatest possible distinctness, and to expound them so clearly as to make
them intelligible to all.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account