Reinke[988] in his lichen studies states that it might not be impossible for a saprophytic fungus to be derived from a crustaceous lichen—a case of reversion—but that no such instance was then known. More exact studies[989] of parasymbiosis and antagonistic symbiosis have shown the wide range of possible life-conditions, and such a reversion does not seem improbable. We must also bear in mind that in suitable cultures, lichen hyphae can be grown without gonidia: they develop in that case as saprophytes. On Reinke’s[988] view, however, that these saprophytic species, belonging to different genera in the Coniocarpineae, are true fungi, they would represent the direct and closely related ancestors of the corresponding lichen genera, giving a polyphyletic origin within this group. As fungus genera he has united them in Protocaliciaceae, and the representatives among fungi he distinguishes, as does Wainio[990], under such names as _Mycocalicium_ and _Mycoconiocybe_. If we might consider the saprophytic forms as also retrogressive lichens, a monophyletic origin from some remote fungal ancestor would prove a more satisfactory solution of the inheritance problem. This view is even supported by a comparison Reinke himself has drawn between the development of the fructification in _Mycocalicium parietinum_, a saprophyte, and in his view a fungus, and _Chaenotheca chrysocephala_, a closely allied lichen. Both grow on old timber. In the former (the fungus), the mycelium pervades the outer weathered wood-cells, and the fruit stalk rises from a clump of brownish hyphae; there is no trace of gonidia. _Chaenotheca chrysocephala_ differs in the presence of gonidia which are associated with the mycelium in scattered granular warts; but the fruit stalk here also rises directly from the mycelium between the granules. The presence of a lichen thallus chiefly differentiates between the two plants, and this thallus is not a casual or recent association; it is constant and of great antiquity as it is richly provided with lichen-acids. Reinke has indicated the course of evolution within the series but that is on the lines of thalline development and will be considered later.