Life and literature in the Roman republicFrank, Tenney
History
Life and literature in the Roman republic
Frank, Tenney
Latin literature -- History and criticism; Rome -- Intellectual life
Now of course this sort of exposition is too explicit to satisfy modern
taste.[7] It is sometimes excused with the reminder that ancient comedies
were written for a single performance and must be understood at first
presentation without the aid of reviewers’ comments or playbills; and
it is sometimes explained as a concession to witless audiences—on whom
Horace, following Peripatetic critics, blamed most literary crudities.
Such explanations sufficed in the days when we could attribute this
undue explicitness to Plautus, but now that we have discovered Menander
given to the same type of technique we ought to look farther. The
important fact seems to be that the Greek audience was accustomed to
preparation and to the devices which the consequent construction of the
play demanded, and that the originators of the early New Comedy followed
custom. And since in tragedy the general knowledge of the myths used in
the plots obviated use of unexpected catastrophes and compelled writers
to find compensation in tragic irony, so the adoption of the same
method of plot construction for comedy eliminated the use of tension
and increased the employment of a kind of comic irony. The effects of
this comic irony range all the way from what Aristotle terms educated
insolence (πεπαιδευμένη ὕβρις) to genial and sympathetic fellow-feeling,
according as the victim of the delusion is a villain, a braggart, a
buffoon, or a harmless innocent. The foreknowledge which the audience has
of what the players are unconsciously stumbling into provides both the
“sense of superiority,” which Plato found to be an effect of comedy, and
the enjoyment of the incongruous which moderns have often considered its
chief ingredient. This comic irony, concocted like its counterpart in
tragedy, is a large part of the stock in trade of Menander and of Plautus.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account