Lippincott's Magazine of Popular Literature and Science, Vol. 22, September, 1878Various
Science
Lippincott's Magazine of Popular Literature and Science, Vol. 22, September, 1878
Various
Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals; Science -- Periodicals
My marking made me for some time rather unpopular; and beginning at last
to follow the time-honored injunction, "When you are in Rome do as the
Romans do," I hoisted my boys from the sixties and seventies to the more
plausible eighties and nineties. It was, no doubt, an unprincipled thing
to do, but I soothed my outraged conscience with the thought that I was
making a martyr of myself--that when the examination-week arrived the
examiners' reports would confound me by exposing the difference between
my paper and their gold. The examination-week did arrive, of course, and
I found that I was to be myself the examiner of my classes. Let not the
reader think that I would be pleasantly satiric when I say that not till
then did I fully awake to the fruitful meaning of the expression,
"American independence." And neither let him infer that I take such a
school to be a representative American high-class school: I only say
that it is a fair representative of a class of schools that is both
numerous and popular in the cities I have named above. Here, indeed, was
an application of the _sui-juris_ principle that, though it certainly
eased my feeling of apprehension and doubt as to the probable results of
the examination, yet filled me with a vague sense of dissatisfaction.
And the reason is not far to seek: my English training would naturally
have the effect of making me look for a verdict on my work not to my own
notebook, nor even to the principal's returns, but to some higher and
extra-mural authority who should test the attainments of the pupils and
the efficiency of the school by a searching and impartial examination.
In English middle-class schools the advent of the "Oxford and Cambridge
Schools Examination Board" is regarded with no small anxiety by
principals, masters and scholars alike. It marks an epoch in their
lives, and is the only period of the year in which there is anything
like a _rapprochement_ between them, as if in the presence of some
imminent crisis. The eccentric jackanapes who is by turns the butt and
witling of the school stands for once consciously on equal terms with
his principal, and can for once even "cheek" the school-bully with
perfect impunity. All is excitement, anticipation, preparation and much
consuming of midnight oil. Perhaps a very brief account, in conclusion,
of the methods of procedure in these examinations may interest the
reader; and in case he should think that my object in offering my sketch
is to draw an invidious comparison between the English and American
methods of examination, I refer him to an animated and interesting
correspondence in the April issue of the _Nation_ between President
Eliot of Harvard and Professor Adams of Michigan University--a
discussion in which the former gentleman enthusiastically claims for the
English method a degree of excellence which the most ardent home
advocates of the system--who know its _working_ faults as well as its
positive advantages--would hesitate to claim for it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account