Lippincott's Magazine of Popular Literature and Science, Vol. 26, November, 1880Various
History
Lippincott's Magazine of Popular Literature and Science, Vol. 26, November, 1880
Various
Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals; Science -- Periodicals
Not long before I had been in the den of the managing editor of one
of the great metropolitan dailies, and the conversation had turned
on the mass of unavailable communications that flooded his office on
the arrival of every mail. "What is the proportion of accepted to
rejected manuscripts?" I inquired.--"One in a hundred," he replied,
and continued: "It is strange what crude ideas people have as to the
needs and capacities of a daily journal. For instance, in this pile
of 'unavailables' are poems, sketches, love-stories, theological
disquisitions, scientific treatises, book-reviews, political squibs,
biographies and essays on civil and social reform--not one rising
above commonplace, and the majority the veriest trash imaginable;
and this is sent to us in the face of the fact, which ought to be
apparent to all, that we have a regular corps of trained writers and
correspondents."--"And who are the producers of all this matter?" was
my next query.--"Well," said he, "an editor who is harassed by them
three hundred days in the year soon gets to classify them correctly,
I think. There are three great classes. First, the dilettante
scribblers, young men and young women of elegant leisure, who think
literary distinction 'very nice,' and plunge into authorship for a
little pleasant excitement or in the hope of winning fame. There are
often glimpses of talent in the productions of this class, and with
hard work they might succeed; but they only skim the surface, and the
result is that their work doesn't reach even the respectable. The
second class are those who without special talent embark in literature,
expecting to make a living by it. The third class I pity: it consists
of those who have some literary talent and a desire to improve it,
but who lack the gift of expression or the constructive faculty, or
some other requisite, and are simply incapable of producing anything
worth putting in print. It is this class of incompetents that put the
greatest strain on an editor's sensibilities, for their articles are
almost, but never quite, available. If I could reach these literary
aspirants I would whisper in their ears that modern journalism is
an organized, elaborated profession, and that every conductor of a
better-class journal, whether newspaper or magazine, has a corps of
trained writers at command who to literary talent add the experience of
years, and whose contributions are generally satisfactory. Yet it by
no means follows that first-class articles from outside correspondents
are neglected: on the contrary, it is because an occasional nugget
is found that readers are employed to examine their miscellaneous
correspondence. There now!" he added, laughingly, "I have given you
some points for a sermon to the scribbling public, and as you have
plenty of leisure you ought really to improve the opportunity."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account