Lippincott's Magazine of Popular Literature and Science, Volume 11, No. 23, February, 1873Various
Science
Lippincott's Magazine of Popular Literature and Science, Volume 11, No. 23, February, 1873
Various
Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals; Science -- Periodicals
Handbook of the History of Philosophy. By Dr. Albert Schwegler.
Translated arid annotated by James Hutchison Stirling, LL.D. New York:
Putnam.
Spinoza teaches that "substance is God;" but, says Mr. Matthew Arnold,
"propositions about substance pass by mankind at large like the idle
wind, which mankind at large regards not: it will not even listen to
a word about these propositions, unless it first learns what their
author was driving at with them, and finds that this object of his
is one with which it sympathizes." There is no way of getting the
multitude to listen to Spinoza's _Ethics_ or Plato's _Dialectics_ but
something is gained when a man of science like Dr. Schwegler happens
to possess the gift of fluent and easy statement, and can pour into a
work like the present, which is the expansion of a hasty encyclopaedia
article, the vivacity of current speech, and the impulse which gives
unity to a long history while it excludes crabbed digressions. It
happens that the American world received the first translation of
Schwegler's _History_ _of Philosophy_; and it may be asked, What need
have Americans of a subsequent version by a Scotch doctor of laws? The
answer is, that Mr. Seelye's earlier rendering was taken from a first
edition, and that the present one includes the variations made in five
editions which have now been issued. Even on British ground the work
thus translated has reached three editions, and the multitude of
"mankind at large," hearing of these repeated editions in Edinburgh
and of twenty thousand copies sold in Germany, may begin to prick
up its ears, and to think that this is one of the easily-read
philosophies of modern times, of which Taine and Michelet have the
secret. It is not so: abstractions stated with scientific precision in
their elliptic slang or technicality are not and cannot be made easy
reading: the strong hands of condensation which Schwegler pressed down
upon the material he controlled so perfectly have not left it lighter
or more digestible. The reader of this manual, for instance, will be
invited to consider the Eleatic argumentation that nothing exists but
Identity, "which is the beënt, and that Difference, the non-beënt,
does not exist; and therefore that he must not only not go on talking
about difference, but that he must not allude to difference as being
anything but the non-beënt; for if he casts about for a synonym, and
arrives at the notion that he may say non-existent for non-beënt, he
is abjectly wrong, for beënt does not mean existent, and non-beënt
non-existent, but it must be considered that the beënt is strictly the
non-existent, and the existent the non-beënt." Such are the amenities
of expression into which an eloquent metaphysician, trying his best
to speak popularly, is led. Yet the book is readable to that orderly
application of the mind which such studies exact, and is the firmest
and strictest guide now speaking our English tongue. Its steady
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account